← Judged questions

reasoning-018: both judges

A public question in Reasoning, battery v1. It starts: “Amy, Ben, Cara, and Dev sit in a row of 4 seats numbered 1 to 4 from left to right as seen from the front, and 'left of' means a lower seat…” Read the question and every model's answer.

228 models judged; 6 disputed (judges 3 or more points apart). The gap is the distance between the two judges' scores. Models are ordered by that gap, widest first.

DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-14B gap 3, disputed

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 10/10

The response gives the correct seat number, 4, and places it on the required final ANSWER line. It is concise and directly satisfies the task.

The response correctly identifies Ben’s seat as 4 and follows the requested output convention by placing “ANSWER: 4” on the last line. Its brevity is appropriate because the task asks only for the final answer, and no reasoning was required. There is no substantive weakness in the response; although it does not explain the seating deductions, that omission does not reduce task compliance here because the required final value is explicit and correct.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 7/10

The response states Ben sits in seat 4 and gives the final line ANSWER: 4, which matches the reference and the correct verdict. It shows no working, so the argument that the answer follows from the constraints is missing rather than demonstrated.

The response gives the correct final answer, seat 4, on the required last line. Its main strength is that the answer is right and the format requirement is met. Its weakness is that it provides no supporting reasoning: it never shows how Cara in seat 1, Amy immediately left of Ben, and Dev not in seat 4 force Ben into seat 4. The conclusion is therefore asserted rather than justified, though the correctness of the final value is confirmed by the programmatic verdict.

GLM-4.7-Flash gap 3, disputed

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 6/10

The final answer is correct, but the case analysis contains substantive errors: Case 1 violates Cara’s seat-1 placement, and Case 3 is actually valid rather than invalid. The valid arrangement still places Ben in seat 4.

The response correctly identifies seat 4 as Ben’s position and provides a constraint-based case analysis. Its main weakness is that the cases are handled inconsistently: it treats Amy as occupying seat 1 despite Cara already being there, and incorrectly rejects the valid arrangement Cara-Amy? More precisely, with Cara in seat 1, Amy in seat 3, Ben in seat 4, and Dev in seat 2, all constraints are satisfied. Thus the conclusion is right, but the supporting reasoning does not properly establish uniqueness.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 9/10

Verdict is correct and the final answer is 4. The response enumerates the three Amy-Ben pairs, eliminates two with valid reasons, and reaches the single valid arrangement Cara, Amy, Dev, Ben. Minor blemish: Case 1 says Dev must be in seat 3 without stating explicitly that seat 4 is then left for Ben. Argument is sound and concise.

The response correctly concludes that Ben sits in seat 4 and ends with the required answer line. It uses a clear case analysis over the possible Amy-Ben adjacent pairs, eliminating the two cases that place Dev in seat 4 with explicit reasons. The main weakness is that the first case's deduction of Ben's seat is stated only implicitly, since the remaining seat is assigned without an explicit statement of why it must be Ben's. The structure is somewhat more elaborate than the problem requires, though the logic holds throughout.

Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct gap 3, disputed

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 10/10

The response correctly identifies the only possible Amy-Ben pairs, eliminates seats 2–3 because Dev would be forced into prohibited seat 4, and concludes that Ben sits in seat 4. The final answer matches the reference and required form.

The response gives a clear constraint-based derivation. Its strength is that it explicitly considers both consecutive placements available to Amy and Ben after placing Cara, then uses Dev’s restriction to eliminate one placement. The conclusion that Amy occupies seat 3 and Ben occupies seat 4 follows directly from the remaining arrangement. There is no substantive weakness; the explanation is somewhat more structured than necessary, but every stated step is relevant and consistent with the seating constraints.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 7/10

Final answer 4 matches the verdict of correct. The response correctly places Cara in seat 1 and identifies that Amy and Ben must occupy seats 3 and 4. However, Step 3 mistakenly says Amy and Ben in seats 2 and 3 would force Dev into seat 4, which is a muddled deduction, and Step 2 wrongly suggests Amy and Ben could be in seats 3 and 4 'respectively'. The justification is partly flawed though the conclusion holds.

The response reaches the correct final answer, seat 4 for Ben, and correctly notes that Cara occupies seat 1 and that Amy and Ben must be adjacent. Its main weakness is the elimination argument: Step 3 claims that Amy and Ben in seats 2 and 3 would put Dev in seat 4, but Dev could instead occupy seat 4 only if Amy and Ben fill 2 and 3 with Dev there, and the reasoning does not clearly show why the remaining case is forced. The step order is also a little tangled, though the answer line is present and the verdict is supported.

Phi3 14B Medium 128K Instruct gap 3, disputed

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 6/10

The response reaches the correct answer, seat 4, but incorrectly claims Amy must sit in seat 2. The valid alternative pair Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4 is actually the only arrangement surviving Dev's constraint; the response's conclusion is right despite flawed reasoning.

The response correctly identifies Ben’s seat as 4 and attempts to use the adjacency and Dev constraints to determine the arrangement. Its key weakness is the unsupported claim that Amy must occupy seat 2: Amy could instead occupy seat 3 with Ben in seat 4, while Dev occupies seat 2. In fact, the Dev constraint rules out the seat-2/seat-3 pair rather than forcing it. Thus, the final answer is correct, but the explanation reaches it through an invalid intermediate deduction.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 9/10

Final answer 4 matches the programmatic verdict of correct. The response derives seat 2 for Amy from Cara in seat 1 and Amy left of Ben, then uses Dev not in seat 4 to force Dev into seat 3 and Ben into seat 4. The argument is concise and every step follows; the ANSWER line is present.

The response reaches the correct final answer, seat 4, through a short and valid deduction. It correctly places Amy in seat 2 from the adjacency constraint and Cara's fixed seat, then applies the restriction on Dev to fix the remaining two seats. Its strength is the minimal, step-by-step logic with no unstated leaps. A minor weakness is that it does not explicitly check the constraint that Amy and Ben occupy consecutive seats after assigning Ben to seat 4, though this follows directly. The answer is given on the required final line.

Qwen2.5-32B-Instruct gap 3, disputed

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 10/10

The response correctly enumerates the only possible Amy-Ben consecutive pairs after placing Cara in seat 1. It eliminates seats 2–3 because Dev would be forced into seat 4, then correctly identifies the valid arrangement with Ben in seat 4.

The response gives a clear, complete deduction from the seating constraints. Its strength is that it explicitly considers both remaining consecutive seat pairs and explains why the first is invalid under the condition on Dev. It then verifies the second arrangement by placing Dev in seat 2 and concludes that Ben occupies seat 4. The reasoning is logically sound, includes the requested final-answer format, and contains no irrelevant claims or unsupported assumptions.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 7/10

Final answer 4 matches the programmatic verdict of correct. The argument correctly places Cara in seat 1 and tests consecutive Amy-Ben pairs. However, it contains a logic slip: it rejects the (2,3) case because Dev would be in seat 4, which is valid reasoning, but it then says Dev must be in seat 2 in the (3,4) case without checking the remaining seat arithmetic carefully, leaving the derivation partly unjustified.

The response reaches the correct seat for Ben, 4, and lays out the case analysis over consecutive Amy-Ben pairs. Its main strength is organizing the constraints clearly and arriving at a consistent arrangement. Its weakness is in the case analysis: it dismisses the (2,3) arrangement with wording that does not clearly follow from the constraint that Dev cannot sit in seat 4, and it does not explicitly confirm that the remaining seat assignment satisfies every condition. The final answer is correct, but the justification is less tight than it could be.

Qwen3.5 2B gap 3, disputed

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 3/10

The response correctly eliminates the (Amy=1, Ben=2) arrangement and notices the contradiction in (Amy=2, Ben=3), but it incorrectly omits the valid pair Amy=3, Ben=4. Thus Dev can sit in seat 2 and Ben is 4. It also provides no required final ANSWER line.

The response systematically applies several constraints and correctly recognizes that Cara occupying seat 1 eliminates the first adjacent pair. Its decisive weakness is the claim that Amy and Ben cannot occupy seats 3 and 4; that pair is valid, with Dev in seat 2, and directly yields the reference answer. Because this omitted case leads the response to an apparent contradiction, it does not answer the question and ends without the required final-answer format.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 0/10

The response never reaches a final answer. It correctly derives Amy=2, Ben=3, Dev=4, then wrongly concludes a contradiction, misreading the constraints. It ends mid-deliberation with no ANSWER line. Programmatic verdict is correct for answer 4, so the band is 0-3, and no usable answer is given.

The response sets up the problem clearly and correctly identifies that Amy and Ben must occupy seats 2 and 3, since Cara holds seat 1. It then derives that Dev must sit in seat 4, which the response mistakenly treats as a contradiction with the rule that Dev is not in seat 4. The error is a misreading of the constraint, since Dev is not in seat 4 is satisfied only if Dev is elsewhere, which the response fails to resolve. The response stops mid-analysis, reconsidering the wording without giving the ANSWER line, so no final answer for Ben's seat is delivered.

Deepseek R1 8B Llama Distill gap 2

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 10/10

The response gives a valid arrangement: Cara in seat 1, Dev in seat 2, Amy in seat 3, and Ben in seat 4. It satisfies Amy immediately left of Ben, Cara in seat 1, and Dev not in seat 4, and the final answer matches the reference.

The response correctly identifies a seating arrangement satisfying every stated constraint and clearly places Ben in seat 4. Its concise explanation directly connects the arrangement to the conditions, and the final answer uses the requested format on the last line. The response does not explicitly explain why the constraints rule out other placements, but that omission is minor because the requested seat follows directly from the available four-seat arrangement and the stated restrictions. Overall, the reasoning is complete enough for this elementary deduction.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 8/10

Final answer 4 matches the programmatic verdict of correct. The response gives a valid arrangement (Cara 1, Dev 2, Amy 3, Ben 4) that satisfies Amy-left-of-Ben, Cara in seat 1, and Dev not in seat 4. It does not show the reasoning for why this is the only possibility, so the argument is brief but sound for the answer given.

The response reaches the correct final answer, Ben in seat 4, and provides a concrete seating arrangement that meets all stated constraints, which lets the reader verify the result directly. Its main weakness is that it presents one valid arrangement without explaining why no other arrangement is possible, so uniqueness is asserted rather than justified. The response is concise and stays on the question, with no extraneous material and no formatting problems.

Gemma 3n E4B IT gap 2

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 8/10

The response reaches the correct answer, ANSWER: 4, and its case analysis correctly eliminates Amy/Ben in seats (1,2) and (2,3), leaving (3,4). It contains an earlier contradictory sentence claiming the first arrangement is possible despite Dev being in seat 4, but this is immediately corrected and does not affect the final reasoning.

The response correctly identifies the only feasible arrangement as Cara, Dev, Amy, Ben and explicitly verifies each condition. Its case-by-case analysis provides sound support for Ben being in seat 4. However, it unnecessarily repeats the reasoning and includes a contradictory intermediate statement that the arrangement with Dev in seat 4 is possible, before later recognizing that this violates the constraint. The final conclusion and subsequent detailed analysis resolve the mistake.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 6/10

Final answer 4 matches the programmatic verdict of correct. The response reaches it after a messy, self-contradictory exploration: it first declares an impossible arrangement (Cara, Amy, Ben, Dev) valid, then Cara, Dev, Amy, Ben, and only later performs the clean case analysis that justifies seat 4. The final case analysis is sound, but the write-up is cluttered with repeated and incorrect intermediate claims.

The response arrives at the correct final answer, seat 4, and its closing case analysis correctly eliminates the adjacent-pair placements in seats 1-2 and 2-3 and identifies Cara, Dev, Amy, Ben as the only valid arrangement. Its main weakness is presentation: it first lists an arrangement that violates the Dev constraint and says it is valid, then repeats the analysis from scratch. The contradictory early reasoning and redundant restatements weaken the argument's clarity, even though the justification that is ultimately given holds.

gemma-3-4b-it gap 2

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 2/10

The response correctly identifies arrangements where Ben is in seat 4, but repeatedly and incorrectly claims adjacent Amy–Ben placements violate the condition. It never supplies the required final ANSWER line and ends mid-analysis.

The response does make useful progress by placing Cara in seat 1 and recognizing that Amy and Ben must form an adjacent ordered pair. It also repeatedly reaches Ben in seat 4 in its constructed cases. However, it then misreads immediate adjacency, incorrectly rejects valid arrangements, and introduces further contradictory eliminations, including treating Dev in seats 2 or 3 as invalid. The response ends abruptly without a final answer in the requested format, so its reasoning is not a reliable completed solution.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 0/10

The response is incoherent and contradicts itself repeatedly, misreading 'immediately to the left' and rejecting valid arrangements. It never reaches a final answer; the output ends mid-reasoning with 'Let's reconsider the arrangement' and no ANSWER line. The programmatic verdict is incorrect and no usable answer can be read.

The response attempts a seat-by-seat case analysis, correctly placing Cara in seat 1 and recognising that Dev cannot occupy seat 4. However, it repeatedly misapplies the adjacency constraint, labelling valid arrangements as contradictions and discarding them. It loops through several restarts with the same errors and never commits to a conclusion. The output stops mid-thought without the required final ANSWER line, so no seat for Ben is given.

Gemma2 27B Instruct gap 2

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 3/10

The response derives the arrangement Cara–Dev–Amy–Ben, which places Ben in seat 4, but it incorrectly states “ANSWER: 3.” The final answer therefore contradicts its own arrangement and the reference answer.

The response correctly applies the seating constraints and identifies the only valid arrangement, with Cara in seat 1, Dev in seat 2, Amy in seat 3, and Ben in seat 4. Its central weakness is the final extraction: it reports seat 3 even though the arrangement explicitly places Ben in seat 4. This is a near-final transcription or reading error rather than a failure to solve the seating logic, but the required answer is nonetheless wrong.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 1/10

Verdict is incorrect and the reference answer is 4. The response places Cara in seat 1, then asserts the arrangement Cara, Dev, Amy, Ben, which puts Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4 but yields the final answer 3. The answer 3 contradicts its own arrangement, where Ben occupies seat 4. The reasoning is wrong from the start, with unsupported claims like 'Dev does not sit in seat 4' leaving seat 4 open for Amy and Ben.

The response correctly places Cara in seat 1 and recognises that Amy and Ben must occupy adjacent seats. It then asserts an arrangement, Cara, Dev, Amy, Ben, that does not follow from the constraints. The stated arrangement places Ben in seat 4, yet the final line reports seat 3, so the answer contradicts the model's own work. The response also never checks the remaining Dev constraint against its arrangement. The attempt at a structured solution is clear, but the conclusion is not supported by the reasoning shown.

Hermes-3-Llama-3.1-8B gap 2

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 6/10

The response gives the reference answer, 4, and follows the requested final-answer format. However, its reasoning incorrectly claims Amy must be in seat 2: Amy could be in seat 3 with Ben in seat 4, while Dev occupies seat 2. The conclusion matches the supplied verdict, but the justification is incomplete and overstates necessity.

The response correctly identifies seat 4 and presents the answer on the required final line. It also uses the seat constraints in an orderly way. However, it incorrectly treats Amy’s placement as forced: the arrangement Cara 1, Dev 2, Amy 3, Ben 4 also satisfies all stated conditions. Thus, the response reaches the expected answer but does not establish that it is uniquely determined; its elimination argument omits a valid alternative arrangement.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 8/10

Final answer 4 matches the programmatic verdict of correct. The argument places Cara in seat 1, Amy in seat 2 (immediately left of Ben), Dev in seat 3 because Dev cannot be in seat 4, and Ben in seat 4 by elimination. The chain is sound and concise, though it does not explicitly check that Amy-Ben adjacency is consistent with the remaining options.

The response reaches the correct seat for Ben, 4, and gives a short deduction that follows the constraints in order: Cara fixed in seat 1, Amy placed immediately left of Ben, Dev excluded from seat 4, and Ben assigned the remaining seat. The argument is compact and avoids padding. A minor weakness is that it does not explicitly verify that Amy in seat 2 and Ben in seat 3 was ruled out, relying on elimination without showing why the alternative placement fails. The final answer line follows the required format.

Ministral 3 8B Instruct 2512 gap 2

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 7/10

The response correctly eliminates the arrangement with Dev in seat 4 and concludes that Ben must be in seat 4. However, it is highly repetitive, ends abruptly after “Therefore,” and does not provide the required final line in the specified ANSWER format.

The response correctly identifies both possible adjacent Amy–Ben placements and uses the restriction on Dev to reject the placement where Dev occupies seat 4. This establishes Ben’s seat correctly. Its main weakness is presentation: it repeatedly revisits the same conclusion, includes unnecessary self-corrections, and terminates abruptly without writing the explicitly requested “ANSWER: 4” final line. The reasoning remains understandable despite that incomplete ending.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 5/10

The response reaches the correct final answer (seat 4) via a valid arrangement, but the working is extremely repetitive, self-contradictory mid-stream ('Wrong, this contradicts...'), and it briefly states Dev is in seat 4 as valid before correcting. The argument is ultimately sound but messy and padded, and the answer line is cut off before the required ANSWER line.

The response correctly identifies Ben's seat as 4 and derives the arrangement Cara, Dev, Amy, Ben, which satisfies all constraints. Its main strength is that the final deduction is valid. Its main weakness is presentation: it repeatedly restarts its reasoning, labels earlier attempts as violating constraints and then reverses itself, and several passages repeat the same case analysis. The text also ends mid-sentence ('Therefore') without the required final ANSWER line, so the response is incomplete as delivered.

Mistral Small 3.2 24B Instruct (2506) gap 2

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 10/10

The response correctly derives that Ben cannot be in seats 1 or 2, tests seat 3 and shows Dev would have no permissible seat, then identifies the valid arrangement with Cara 1, Dev 2, Amy 3, and Ben 4. The final answer matches the reference.

The response clearly translates each seating condition into positional constraints and checks the remaining possibilities. Its strongest feature is the explicit contradiction for Ben in seat 3, followed by a complete valid arrangement for Ben in seat 4. The reasoning is logically sound and the required final-answer format is followed exactly. The only minor weakness is that some preliminary statements, such as listing Dev’s possible seats, are somewhat repetitive, but they do not introduce any error or undermine the conclusion.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 8/10

Final answer 4 matches the programmatic verdict of correct. The argument checks seat cases for Ben and tests Dev's constraint. The reasoning has a flaw: it says Ben in seat 3 forces Dev into seat 1 or 3, which is an unclear step, though the conclusion holds. Final line gives ANSWER: 4 as required.

The response reaches the correct final answer, seat 4, and places the ANSWER line on the last line as requested. It works through the possible positions for Ben and Amy, eliminating seats 1 and 2 with clear reasons. Its weakness lies in the seat-3 case, where the claim that Dev must occupy seat 1 or 3 is muddled, since seat 2 is left open and was not considered. The overall argument still supports the conclusion, but that elimination is less rigorous than it appears.

Phi-4-mini-instruct gap 2

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 6/10

The final answer, 4, matches the reference. However, the response incorrectly claims Amy must be in seat 2. The valid arrangement is Cara 1, Dev 2, Amy 3, and Ben 4; the stated conclusion is reached through faulty intermediate reasoning.

The response correctly identifies Ben’s seat as 4 and recognizes that the restriction on Dev determines which adjacent Amy–Ben placement is possible. Its weakness is a specific logical error: Cara’s position does not force Amy into seat 2, since Amy could be in seat 3 with Ben in seat 4. In fact, the Dev restriction rules out the former placement and supports the latter. Thus, the final result is correct, but the supporting argument does not justify it as written.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 8/10

The response places Cara in seat 1, deduces Amy in seat 2 from adjacency, and Dev in seat 3 since Dev cannot be in seat 4, concluding Ben is in seat 4. The final line reads ANSWER: 4, matching the correct verdict. The argument is brief and sound, with only a small unstated step about Amy-Ben adjacency forcing Ben into seat 3 or 4 being skipped over.

The response reaches the correct final answer, seat 4, with a compact deduction. It correctly fixes Cara in seat 1, uses the immediate-left constraint to place Amy in seat 2, and uses Dev's restriction to fill seat 3. The main weakness is that it does not explicitly check the remaining case or verify that the arrangement satisfies all constraints, leaving a small gap in justification. The formatting follows the requested final-line answer convention without extraneous text.

Qwen2.5-VL-32B-Instruct gap 2

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 10/10

The response correctly fixes Cara in seat 1, evaluates both possible adjacent placements for Amy and Ben, rejects seats 2–3 because Dev would be in seat 4, and identifies the unique valid arrangement with Ben in seat 4. It also provides the required final-answer format.

The response gives a complete and logically sound deduction. It correctly identifies the only possible adjacent placements for Amy and Ben after placing Cara, then uses Dev’s restriction to eliminate the seats 2–3 placement. The resulting arrangement is consistent with every condition, and the final line states the required answer as “ANSWER: 4.” The explanation is somewhat more detailed than necessary for this simple constraint problem, but it contains no substantive gap or error.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 8/10

The verdict is correct and the final answer is ANSWER: 4. The response eliminates scenarios and finds the valid arrangement Cara, Dev, Amy, Ben, which satisfies all constraints. Scenario 1 has a minor flaw: it states Dev is in seat 4 without noting Dev's placement is forced, and it doesn't check the case where Amy-Ben occupy seats 2-3 with Dev in seat 4 more rigorously. Argument is mostly sound.

The response reaches the correct final answer, seat 4 for Ben, and identifies the valid arrangement Cara, Dev, Amy, Ben. Its strongest point is the explicit check of the Amy-Ben placements against the constraint that Dev cannot occupy seat 4. Its weakness is the handling of Scenario 1, where it asserts Dev must sit in seat 4 without fully enumerating the remaining placements, leaving a small unjustified step. The layout is heavier with headers than the problem requires, though the logic remains traceable and the conclusion is supported.

Qwen3-Coder-30B-A3B-Instruct gap 2

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 10/10

The response correctly enumerates the possible adjacent Amy–Ben pairs, eliminates Amy in seat 1 because Cara occupies it, and rejects Amy in seat 2 because Dev would be forced into seat 4. It correctly concludes Ben is in seat 4 and gives the required final-answer format.

The response systematically applies all three seating constraints and checks both remaining adjacent-pair cases. Its strongest feature is the explicit verification of the surviving arrangement, including Dev in seat 2 and Ben in seat 4. The only minor weakness is a momentary self-correction in the first case, where it initially says the arrangement satisfies the Dev constraint before recognizing that it violates it. Because the correction is immediate and the final reasoning is complete, it does not affect the conclusion.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 8/10

Final answer 4 matches the verdict of correct. The response correctly eliminates Amy in seat 1 and tests Case 1, which puts Dev in seat 4, violating the constraint. It then verifies Case 2 against all constraints. The Case 1 check contains a confused sentence ('This satisfies... but wait') before rejecting it, a minor blemish.

The response reaches the correct final answer, seat 4, through a logically sound case analysis. It rules out Amy in seat 1 because Cara occupies that seat, then tests both remaining adjacent placements against the Dev constraint. The second case is verified against every condition before the conclusion is stated. A weakness is the Case 1 discussion, which first says the arrangement satisfies the Dev constraint and only then reverses itself, making that step harder to follow than necessary. The derivation is otherwise clear and complete.

Aya 8B 23 gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 1/10

The response gives “ANSWER: 2,” but the supplied verdict and reference establish that the correct seat is 4. It provides no reasoning or constraint analysis to support its incorrect answer.

The response does follow the requested final-answer format and is concise. However, it identifies Ben’s seat as 2, which conflicts with the stated constraints and the reference answer of 4. It also supplies no explanation, so there is no demonstrated attempt to place Amy, Ben, Cara, and Dev systematically. The answer is therefore an unsubstantiated incorrect conclusion rather than a near miss supported by mostly correct reasoning.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 0/10

The response gives only 'ANSWER: 2' with no supporting reasoning. The programmatic verdict is incorrect and the reference answer is 4. Ben cannot be in seat 2 if Amy is immediately left of him and Cara is in seat 1, since that would place Amy in seat 1, which is occupied by Cara. No argument is offered.

The response consists solely of a final answer line giving seat 2 for Ben. This is incorrect: with Cara fixed in seat 1, Amy and Ben must occupy adjacent seats 2 and 3 or 3 and 4, and the Dev constraint leaves Ben in seat 4 as the only consistent placement. The response shows no derivation, so no reasoning can be credited. It meets the required answer-line format but provides no attempted work to evaluate.

Aya Expanse 8B gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 7/10

The final answer is correct and the response identifies that Ben must be in seat 4. However, it incorrectly claims that Amy must be in seat 2; the valid arrangement is Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4, with Dev in seat 2. The conclusion is right but the deduction is not properly justified.

The response correctly gives seat 4 and reaches the reference answer. It also recognizes that Cara’s placement constrains the adjacent Amy–Ben pair. However, the stated intermediate deduction that Amy must be in seat 2 is false: that arrangement would put Dev in seat 4, violating the condition, while Amy can instead be in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4. The response therefore has the correct result but an incomplete and partly incorrect explanation of why the alternative arrangement is eliminated.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 6/10

Final answer 4 matches the programmatic verdict of correct. The argument is thin: it asserts Amy must be in seat 2 without covering the placements of Dev, and the step 'if Dev doesn't sit in seat 4, Ben must sit in seat 4' is an unjustified leap, since Dev's exclusion alone does not force Ben into seat 4.

The response reaches the correct final answer, seat 4, and states it on the required final line. Its main weakness is the supporting argument. It places Amy in seat 2 correctly, but then concludes that Ben must be in seat 4 because Dev is not, which does not follow without enumerating where Dev and Amy-Ben can sit. The derivation skips the case analysis that would justify the answer, so the correct result is not actually established by the shown reasoning.

Codegemma 2B Code V1.1 gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 1/10

The response gives “ANSWER: 2,” which is incorrect. With Cara in seat 1, the only feasible adjacent Amy–Ben placement is Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4, because the alternative would place Dev in seat 4.

The response at least provides a clearly formatted candidate answer using the requested ANSWER label. However, it supplies no reasoning and reaches the wrong seat number. The constraints eliminate Ben in seat 2: that would require Amy in seat 1, conflicting with Cara, while the remaining possible arrangement places Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4. Thus the response does not solve the seating deduction and fails the required final result.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 0/10

The response contains only an example line 'ANSWER: 2' with no reasoning. Verdict is incorrect; the reference answer is 4. The response is not a genuine attempt at the task, and the value given is wrong.

The response consists solely of a template-like line reading 'ANSWER: 2' copied from the example, with no reasoning about seating constraints. It does not engage with the Amy, Ben, Cara, and Dev arrangement at all. Its only apparent strength is that it follows the requested final-line answer format. Its weakness is that the value is wrong, since Ben must sit in seat 4 given Cara in seat 1 and Amy immediately left of Ben. No derivation is shown, so nothing in the response supports the answer it gives.

Codegemma 7B Instruct V1.1 gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 1/10

The response incorrectly infers that Dev must be in seat 3. It overlooks that Amy and Ben can occupy seats 3 and 4 respectively; with Cara in seat 1, Dev then occupies seat 2, satisfying all constraints. Its final answer of 2 is wrong.

The response correctly notices two relevant constraints: Cara occupies seat 1 and Dev cannot occupy seat 4. However, it makes an unsupported inference that Dev must therefore be in seat 3, without considering the possible adjacent Amy–Ben placements. Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4 forces Dev into seat 2 and satisfies every condition. The claimed arrangement also cannot place Amy immediately left of Ben while Cara remains in seat 1, so the final answer does not follow from the stated reasoning.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 2/10

Verdict is incorrect and the reference answer is 4. The response places Dev in seat 3 from the constraints, which is reasonable, but then states Amy-Ben placement without checking remaining seats. Ben in seat 2 would force Amy into seat 1, conflicting with Cara's fixed seat 1, so the argument is wrong from the start.

The response correctly fixes Cara in seat 1 and deduces Dev must occupy seat 3, a valid step. However, it then asserts Ben must sit in seat 2 without considering that Amy would need seat 1, which Cara already occupies. The reasoning ignores the seat-occupancy constraint entirely, leading to an incorrect final answer. The response is brief and does not show any check of the resulting arrangement.

Codellama 34B Instruct gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 1/10

The response supplies a clearly formatted final answer, but it states 3, which conflicts with the reference answer 4 and the programmatic verdict. It provides no reasoning to support or diagnose the incorrect placement.

The response has the limited strength of following the requested final-answer format and presenting a single unambiguous value. However, the stated seat number is incorrect: Ben must be in seat 4 under the given constraints, whereas the response says 3. It also offers no reasoning, so it does not demonstrate how the seating conditions were interpreted or where the incorrect conclusion came from.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 0/10

The response is only 'ANSWER: 3' with no reasoning shown. Verdict is incorrect; the correct answer is seat 4 (Cara 1, Amy 2, Ben 3? check: Amy-Ben adjacent, Dev not in 4, so Dev 2 or 3, Amy/Ben occupy remaining pair 3-4 forcing Ben 4). The response gives no usable argument and the wrong seat.

The response supplies only a bare final line, 'ANSWER: 3', with no reasoning or working shown. The required format is satisfied, so the answer is at least readable. However, the seat it names is incorrect: with Cara fixed in seat 1 and Dev barred from seat 4, Amy and Ben must occupy seats 3 and 4, placing Ben in seat 4. The model provided no attempt that could reveal where its reasoning went wrong.

Cogito 14B V1 Preview Qwen gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 2/10

The response gives the wrong answer, 3. It incorrectly excludes Amy and Ben occupying seats 3 and 4; that arrangement leaves Dev in seat 2 and satisfies all constraints. It also assigns Dev to seat 4 while explicitly noting Dev cannot sit there.

The response correctly identifies that Amy must sit immediately before Ben and correctly places Cara in seat 1. However, it makes the decisive logical error of claiming that Amy and Ben cannot occupy seats 3 and 4. In fact, that is the only valid arrangement: Cara is in seat 1, Dev is in seat 2, Amy is in seat 3, and Ben is in seat 4. The response also contradicts a stated constraint by assigning Dev to seat 4, so its final conclusion is unsupported.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 1/10

The response places Cara in seat 1, then Amy in 2 and Ben in 3, and concludes ANSWER: 3. The programmatic verdict is incorrect and the reference is 4. Its error is a false claim that Amy and Ben cannot occupy seats 3 and 4, which is unjustified. Ignores the Dev constraint in a way that leads to the wrong seat.

The response correctly records that Cara occupies seat 1 and lays out its reasoning in numbered steps. Its main weakness is the claim that Amy and Ben cannot occupy seats 3 and 4, which has no basis in the stated constraints. Since Cara is in seat 1, Amy and Ben can occupy seats 2 and 3 or seats 3 and 4. Placing Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4 with Dev in seat 2 satisfies every condition. The final answer of seat 3 is therefore wrong, even though the presentation is clear and well organized.

Command R7B (12-2024) gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 2/10

The response correctly identifies the viable consecutive-seat cases and initially observes that Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4 leaves Dev in seat 2. It then incorrectly rejects this valid arrangement, invents an arrangement placing Dev in seat 4, and concludes Ben is in seat 3.

The response makes a useful start by placing Cara in seat 1 and enumerating consecutive positions for Amy and Ben. It also briefly identifies the valid arrangement with Amy in seat 3, Ben in seat 4, and Dev in seat 2. However, it mistakenly treats that arrangement as contradictory, despite Dev being in seat 2, and later claims that Dev in seat 4 satisfies the condition that Dev is not in seat 4. The final answer is therefore incorrect, and the reasoning becomes internally inconsistent near the conclusion.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 1/10

The verdict is incorrect and the final answer ANSWER: 3 is wrong; the reference is 4. The response's own reasoning contradicts itself: it places Dev in seat 4 while stating Dev is not in seat 4, then asserts the arrangement satisfies all conditions. The correct arrangement is Cara 1, Dev 2, Amy 3, Ben 4.

The response works through the seating constraints step by step, correctly placing Cara in seat 1 and noting that Amy must immediately precede Ben. However, it repeatedly places Dev in seat 4, which the task explicitly forbids, and then declares that arrangement valid. It never tests the option of Amy in seat 3 with Ben in seat 4 and Dev in seat 2 as a complete solution, so it reaches the wrong seat for Ben. The internal contradictions undermine the final answer.

Command R7B Arabic 7B 02 2025 gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 3/10

The response correctly places Cara in seat 1 and identifies the two possible adjacent Amy–Ben placements. However, it incorrectly rejects Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4: Dev can occupy seat 2, so Dev’s restriction does not rule out Ben in seat 4. It therefore gives the wrong final answer.

The response’s strength is that it correctly translates the adjacency condition and narrows the arrangement to the relevant remaining seats. Its weakness is a decisive constraint error: it treats Ben being in seat 4 as impossible because Dev cannot be there, even though those are different people and Dev could sit in seat 2. This invalidates the claimed “only valid arrangement” and leads to ANSWER: 3 instead of the reference answer, 4.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 2/10

Final answer ANSWER: 3 is wrong; the reference is 4 and the verdict is incorrect. The response correctly places Cara in seat 1 and rules out Amy in seat 3, but then wrongly assumes Dev must be in seat 4 in the arrangement, which contradicts the constraint that Dev is not in seat 4. The arrangement Cara, Dev, Amy, Ben satisfies all constraints, so the reasoning goes wrong early.

The response sets up the constraints clearly and correctly fixes Cara in seat 1. It also correctly eliminates Amy in seat 3 by noting Ben would then need seat 4. However, it then places Dev in seat 4, directly violating the stated condition that Dev does not sit in seat 4. It never considers Dev in seat 2 with Amy and Ben in seats 3 and 4, which is the valid arrangement leading to Ben in seat 4. The final answer of 3 is therefore incorrect, and the reasoning overlooks a valid case.

Deepcoder 14B Preview gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 8/10

The response gives the correct answer, ANSWER: 4, and presents a consistent arrangement. However, it asserts that Amy must be in seat 3 without explicitly ruling out the alternative adjacent placement (Amy 2, Ben 3), which is invalid because Dev would then occupy seat 4.

The response correctly identifies Ben’s seat and provides a complete seating arrangement consistent with all stated constraints. It also implicitly uses the restriction on Dev’s placement by assigning Dev to seat 2. Its main weakness is that it does not explicitly explain why Amy and Ben cannot occupy seats 2 and 3; that alternative would force Dev into seat 4. The conclusion remains supported by checking the possible arrangements, but the elimination step is left unstated rather than demonstrated.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 9/10

Final answer ANSWER: 4 matches the programmatic verdict of correct. The response places Cara in seat 1, Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4, with Dev in seat 2, which satisfies all constraints. The justification is brief but each placement is stated, though it asserts Amy must be in seat 3 without showing why Ben cannot be in seat 2 or 3.

The response reaches the correct final answer, seat 4, and presents a complete seating arrangement that satisfies the constraints: Cara in seat 1, Amy immediately left of Ben, and Dev not in seat 4. The arrangement is listed clearly and the final line follows the requested ANSWER format. The main weakness is that the derivation is asserted rather than argued: it states that Amy must be in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4 without explaining the elimination of the other possible Amy-Ben pairs, such as seats 2 and 3, which leaves the uniqueness step implicit.

Deepscaler 1.5B Preview gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 9/10

The response correctly enumerates the only possible adjacent Amy–Ben pairs after placing Cara in seat 1. It eliminates (2,3) because Dev would occupy forbidden seat 4 and selects Ben in seat 4. The conclusion is fully justified, though it does not use the requested final-line format.

The response clearly identifies the remaining seats and checks both possible consecutive placements for Amy and Ben. Its elimination of the first arrangement and validation of the second provide a complete and logically sound justification for Ben’s seat. The main weakness is formatting: the task explicitly requested a final line in the form “ANSWER: <value>,” but the response instead ends with a boxed numeral in prose. This is a minor presentation issue and does not affect the correctness of the reasoning or result.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 8/10

Verdict is correct, and the response reaches Ben in seat 4 with a valid case analysis: Amy-Ben pairs (2,3) fail because Dev would take seat 4, while (3,4) forces Dev into seat 2. The argument is sound and complete, though it ends with a boxed value and omits the required final ANSWER line, a format lapse.

The response correctly identifies Ben's seat as 4. Its main strength is a clear case analysis over the two possible adjacent Amy-Ben pairs, eliminating the (2,3) case because it forces Dev into seat 4. It then verifies the resulting arrangement against all three constraints. Its weakness is formatting: it gives the result as a LaTeX boxed value rather than the requested 'ANSWER: <value>' line on the last line, so the answer is not in the specified form.

Deepseek Coder 1.3B Instruct gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 1/10

The response does not solve the seating constraints. Its loop immediately assigns Ben to seat 1 because 0 is absent from the positions list, ignoring Amy's adjacency to Ben, Cara's fixed seat, and Dev's restriction. It also never provides the correct final answer, 4.

The response at least attempts to provide executable Python rather than an unsupported guess, and it identifies that the seating problem could be approached algorithmically. However, the implemented condition does not represent any stated constraint: checking whether position minus one is absent causes the first position to be selected immediately. The program never models Amy, Cara, or Dev, produces Ben’s position as 1 rather than 4, and does not include the required explicit final-answer line.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 0/10

The response supplies a Python program that never models the people or constraints. It hardcodes positions 1-4 and outputs seat 1 via a meaningless loop, with no reasoning toward the answer and no valid ANSWER line of the requested form. The verdict is incorrect, and the answer is not usable.

The response offers a short Python snippet in place of a solution to the seating puzzle. The snippet does not encode the names, the adjacency rule, Cara's fixed seat, or Dev's restriction, so its loop is unrelated to the question. Its printed result cannot be connected to any valid deduction. The one thing the response does attempt is a runnable program with a labelled output line, but that output is wrong. The response offers no reasoning about who sits where, so no part of the logic can be credited.

Deepseek Coder 33B Instruct gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 2/10

The response correctly notes that if Amy is in seat 3, Ben would be in seat 4, but then introduces the unsupported claim that Ben must be immediately right of Cara. This invalid inference leads to the incorrect final answer, ANSWER: 2, contrary to the constraints and reference answer 4.

The response makes a relevant attempt by applying the immediate-left relationship and recognizing that Amy in seat 3 would place Ben in seat 4. However, it incorrectly treats Cara’s position as imposing the same adjacency relationship on Ben, even though no such condition is stated. It also fails to reconcile its own observation that Amy 3 and Ben 4 satisfy the first condition. Because the unsupported Cara-based inference determines the final answer, the reasoning does not establish the required seat.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 1/10

The response's final answer, ANSWER: 2, is wrong. Its reasoning is internally inconsistent: it first places Amy in seat 3 and Ben in seat 4 without justification, then concludes Ben is in seat 2 from Cara's seat 1 without any valid link. The verdict is incorrect, so the band is 0-3, and the reasoning is wrong from the start.

The response attempts a seat-by-seat deduction but its logic is unsound from the start. It asserts Amy is in seat 3 without basis, then treats Cara's position in seat 1 as implying Ben is in seat 2, which does not follow from the constraints. It does reach a clear final answer line in the required format, which is a minor structural strength. The final value of 2 is incorrect; the constraints force Ben into seat 4 with Amy in seat 3 and Cara in seat 1, so the answer should have been 4.

DeepSeek-Coder-V2-Lite-Instruct gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 7/10

The final answer is correct. The response identifies the two possible adjacent Amy–Ben placements and correctly finds the valid arrangement with Cara in seat 1, Dev in seat 2, Amy in seat 3, and Ben in seat 4. However, it incorrectly describes Dev as able to sit in seat 4 in Case 1 and then inconsistently frames that arrangement as a constraint violation.

The response’s strength is that it enumerates the relevant adjacent placements and reaches the correct seat for Ben, with the valid arrangement explicitly identified. Its weakness is an inconsistent treatment of the first case: after stating that Dev cannot occupy seat 4, it temporarily presents that placement as an arrangement and only later eliminates it. The overall conclusion remains supported once the constraint is applied correctly, but the case analysis contains a real logical presentation error rather than a fully clean derivation.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 6/10

Final answer 4 matches the programmatic verdict of correct. The argument is muddled: it lists Case 1 (C,A,B,D) as valid without checking, then its Case 2 arrangement (1,2,4,3) places Dev in seat 2 and Amy in seat 3, which contradicts its own derivation. The response never clearly eliminates Case 1 or justifies why Ben must be in seat 4.

The response reaches the correct final answer, seat 4 for Ben, and labels it on the required last line. Its reasoning is weak: it enumerates two cases but does not explicitly rule out the first, where Ben sits in seat 3 with Dev in seat 4, which the stated constraints do not forbid. Its elimination step is asserted rather than shown, and the final arrangement it describes is inconsistent with the case it derived earlier. The correct answer is therefore not fully justified by the supporting argument.

DeepSeek-R1-0528-Qwen3-8B gap 1

Judged by J-O + J-A.

Judge A: J-O (openai/gpt-5.6-luna) 10/10

The response correctly identifies the only possible adjacent Amy-Ben pairs, eliminates (2,3) because Dev would be forced into seat 4, and accepts (3,4). It gives the required final line: ANSWER: 4.

The response gives a complete and logically sound deduction. It correctly accounts for Cara occupying seat 1, considers both feasible adjacent placements for Amy and Ben, and uses Dev’s restriction to eliminate the first placement. It then verifies that the remaining arrangement places Dev in seat 2 and satisfies all conditions. The final answer is clearly presented in the requested format. No substantive weakness is present; the explanation is concise while still showing why the alternative arrangement fails.

Judge B: J-A (anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5) 9/10

Final answer 4 matches the programmatic verdict of correct. The response correctly enumerates Amy-Ben adjacent pairs, eliminates (2,3) because Dev would be forced into seat 4, and derives Amy in 3, Ben in 4, Dev in 2. The argument is sound and concise, though it omits explicitly checking the (1,2) pair, which is ruled out by Cara's seat.

The response reaches the correct seat for Ben, seat 4, and the verdict confirms it. Its main strength is a compact case analysis: it rules out the Amy-Ben pair in seats 2 and 3 by showing it forces Dev into seat 4, then places the remaining people consistently. Its weakness is minor: it lists only two candidate pairs without stating why the pair in seats 1 and 2 is impossible, since Cara occupies seat 1. The reasoning is otherwise clear and proportionate to the problem.

The other 198 models

Their judges were closer together. Their scores are listed here; open the model's page for the full answer.

ModelJudgesJudge AJudge BGap
Devstral 24B Small 2505 J-O + J-A 8 7 1
Exaone Deep 7.8B J-O + J-A 7 8 1
EXAONE-3.5-7.8B-Instruct J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Exaone3.5 2.4B Instruct J-O + J-A 7 8 1
Exaone3.5 32B Instruct J-O + J-A 3 2 1
Falcon3 10B Instruct J-O + J-A 8 9 1
Falcon3 3B Instruct J-O + J-A 7 8 1
Flint 40B A2B J-O + J-A 9 8 1
Gemma 2B Instruct V1.1 J-O + J-A 1 0 1
Gemma 4 12B IT J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Gemma 7B Instruct V1.1 J-O + J-A 6 7 1
gemma-3-27b-it J-O + J-A 8 7 1
gemma-4-26B-A4B-it J-O + J-A 10 9 1
gemma-4-31B-it J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Gemma3n E2B IT J-O + J-A 7 8 1
Gemma4 E2B IT J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Gemma4 E4B IT J-O + J-A 10 9 1
GLM-4.5-Air J-O + J-A 10 9 1
gpt-oss-120b J-A + J-D 7 6 1
gpt-oss-20b J-A + J-D 7 6 1
Granite3 Moe 1B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 2 1
Granite3.1 Moe 1B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 0 1
Granite3.1 Moe 3B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 2 1
Granite4 1B H J-O + J-A 1 0 1
Granite4 3B J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Granite4.1 30B J-O + J-A 9 8 1
Granite4.2 8B J-O + J-A 7 6 1
Internlm2 7B Chat V2.5 J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Laguna XS 2.1 J-O + J-A 9 8 1
Lfm3 VL 2B J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Llama-2-7b-chat-hf J-O + J-A 1 2 1
Marco O1 7B J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Medgemma 27B IT J-O + J-A 3 2 1
Meta-Llama-3-8B-Instruct J-O + J-A 3 2 1
Ministral 3 14B Instruct (2512) J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Mistral 7B Instruct V0.3 J-O + J-A 1 2 1
Nanbeige_Nanbeige4.3-33B J-O + J-A 3 2 1
Nemotron 3.5 Bolt E4B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Nemotron 3.5 Lightning 30B A3B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Nemotron Cascade 2 30B A3B J-O + J-A 1 0 1
Nemotron3 33B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
NVIDIA Nemotron 3 Nano 30B-A3B J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Olmo 3.1 32B Instruct J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Olmo-3-7B-Instruct J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Phi-3.5-mini-instruct J-O + J-A 2 1 1
phi-4 J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Qwen 4B Chat V1.5 J-O + J-A 1 0 1
Qwen2 1.5B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Qwen2 Math 7B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Qwen2-VL-7B-Instruct J-O + J-A 1 2 1
Qwen2.5 0.5B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Qwen2.5 Coder 0.5B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct J-O + J-A 1 2 1
Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct J-O + J-A 2 1 1
Qwen3-4B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3-4B-Thinking-2507 J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3-8B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3-Coder-Next J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3-VL-30B-A3B-Instruct J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3-VL-4B-Instruct J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3.5-35B-A3B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3.5-4B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3.5-9B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3.6-27B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Qwen3.6-35B-A3B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
QwQ 32B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Smallthinker 3B Preview J-O + J-A 9 8 1
Solar 10.7B Instruct V1 J-O + J-A 1 2 1
Spark-X2.6-4B J-O + J-A 10 9 1
Tulu3 8B J-O + J-A 1 2 1
YI 34B Chat V1.5 J-O + J-A 3 2 1
YI 9B Chat V1.5 J-O + J-A 1 2 1
YI Coder 9B Chat J-O + J-A 1 2 1
Apertus-8B-Instruct-2509 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Aya Expanse 32B J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Codegeex4 9B All J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Codellama 13B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Codellama 7B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Codeqwen 7B Chat V1.5 J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Codestral 22B V0.1 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Cogito 3B V1 Preview Llama J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Cogito 8B V1 Preview Llama J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Command R 35B 08 2024 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Deepcoder 1.5B Preview J-O + J-A 9 9 0
Deepseek Coder 6.7B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Deepseek Llm 7B Chat J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Deepseek R1 1.5B Qwen Distill J-O + J-A 0 0 0
Deepseek V2 16B Lite Chat J-O + J-A 1 1 0
DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-32B J-O + J-A 10 10 0
DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-7B J-O + J-A 0 0 0
Devstral Small 2 24B Instruct (2512) J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Dolphin Phi 2.7B V2.6 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
dolphin-2.9.1-yi-1.5-34b J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Exaone Deep 2.4B J-O + J-A 8 8 0
Falcon2 11B J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Falcon3 1B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Falcon3 7B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
gemma-2-9b-it J-O + J-A 2 2 0
gemma-3-12b-it J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Gemma2 2B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Gemma3 1B IT J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Glm4 9B Chat J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite Code 3B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Granite Code 8B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
granite-4.1-3b J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite3 Dense 2B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite3 Dense 8B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite3 Moe 3B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Granite3.1 Dense 2B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Granite3.1 Dense 8B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite3.2 2B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite3.2 8B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite3.3 2B J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite3.3 8B J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite4 350M H J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Granite4 Micro H J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite4 Small H J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite4 Tiny H J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite4.1 8B J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Granite4.2 30B J-O + J-A 3 3 0
Granite4.2 3B J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Hermes3 3B Llama3.2 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Internlm2 1.8B Chat V2.5 J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Lfm2 24B J-O + J-A 7 7 0
Lfm2.5 8B A1B J-O + J-A 9 9 0
Lfm3 1.7B J-O + J-A 7 7 0
Llama 4 Scout 17B-16E Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Llama-3.2-3B-Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Llama2 13B Chat J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Llama3.2 1B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Magistral Small (2506) J-O + J-A 0 0 0
Mathstral 7B V0.1 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
medgemma-4b-it J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Medgemma1.5 4B IT J-O + J-A 0 0 0
Ministral 3 3B Instruct 2512 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Mistral Nemo 12B Instruct 2407 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Mistral Small 22B Instruct 2409 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Mistral Small 24B Instruct 2501 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Mistral Small3.1 24B Instruct 2503 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.2 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Mixtral 8x7B Instruct V0.1 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Muse Glimmer 30B J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Nemotron Mini 4B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Olmo-3-7B-Think J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Olmo2 13B 1124 Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Olmo2 7B 1124 Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Opencoder 1.5B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Openthinker 7B V2 J-O + J-A 8 8 0
Ornith 9B J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Ornith-1.5-9B J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Phi 2.7B Chat V2 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Phi-3-mini-4k-instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Phi3 3.8B Mini 128K Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Phi4 Mini Reasoning 3.8B J-O + J-A 8 8 0
Qwen 0.5B Chat V1.5 J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Qwen 1.8B Chat V1.5 J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Qwen 14B Chat V1.5 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Qwen 7B Chat V1.5 J-O + J-A 6 6 0
Qwen2 0.5B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Qwen2 Math 1.5B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Qwen2.5 1.5B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Qwen2.5 Coder 1.5B Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Qwen2.5-14B-Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Qwen2.5-Coder-14B-Instruct J-O + J-A 8 8 0
Qwen2.5-Coder-32B-Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Qwen2.5-Coder-3B-Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Qwen2.5-Coder-7B-Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Qwen2.5-VL-3B-Instruct J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Qwen3 0.6B J-O + J-A 6 6 0
Qwen3 1.7B J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Qwen3 VL 2B Instruct J-O + J-A 9 9 0
Qwen3 VL 2B Thinking J-O + J-A 9 9 0
Qwen3-14B J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Qwen3-30B-A3B J-O + J-A 9 9 0
Qwen3-30B-A3B-Instruct-2507 J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Qwen3-32B J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507 J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Qwen3-VL-32B-Instruct J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Qwen3.5-27B J-O + J-A 10 10 0
Qwen3.8-27B J-O + J-A 9 9 0
Sage-A1.5-Q4_K_M J-O + J-A 9 9 0
Sailor2 1B Chat J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Sailor2 8B Chat J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Smollm2 1.7B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Smollm2 135M Instruct J-O + J-A 6 6 0
Smollm2 360M Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
SmolLM3-3B J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Stable Code 3B Instruct J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Stablelm Zephyr 3B J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Stablelm2 1.6B Chat J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Stablelm2 12B Chat J-O + J-A 2 2 0
Translategemma 12B IT J-O + J-A 2 2 0
YI 6B Chat V1.5 J-O + J-A 2 2 0
YI Coder 1.5B Chat J-O + J-A 1 1 0
Lfm2.5 Thinking 1.2B J-O + J-A — 7 —

Withheld

These models are kept out of the ranking, so none of their scores or reasons are shown:

The judge room names the judges and shows where they disagree most.