instruction-008: both judges
A public question in Instruction following, battery v1. It starts: “Return a JSON object with the keys "name" and "age" describing a fictional character. Output raw JSON only: no code fences, no commentary be…” Read the question and every model's answer.
228 models judged; 1 disputed (judges 3 or more points apart). The gap is the distance between the two judges' scores. Models are ordered by that gap, widest first.
Phi4 Mini Reasoning 3.8B gap 4, disputed
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The final JSON contains exactly the required "name" and "age" keys, is valid, and stays within the word limit. However, the response also includes extensive <think> content, violating the requirement for raw JSON only.
The response correctly provides a valid JSON object with the requested keys and a plausible fictional character value, satisfying the programmatically checked structural constraints. Its main weakness is that it includes a long internal reasoning block before the JSON, rather than returning only raw JSON as explicitly required. The final object itself is concise and properly formed, but the surrounding content makes the complete response noncompliant with the output-format instruction.
The final output {"name": "Phi", "age": 30} is valid JSON with the correct keys and is short enough. However, the response includes a long visible reasoning block before the JSON, violating the instruction for raw JSON only with no commentary, and the reasoning itself runs well past 30 words.
The response produces the requested JSON object with the keys name and age, and the final line itself is valid, correctly keyed, and well within the length limit. Its main weakness is that it emits a lengthy reasoning block before the JSON, which breaks the explicit instruction to output raw JSON only with no commentary and pushes the whole reply far beyond the 30-word cap. The character chosen is also not described as fictional in any way beyond the name, so the answer relies on the reader accepting the bare fields as the requested output.
Command R 35B 08 2024 gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid raw JSON, contains exactly the required keys "name" and "age", describes a fictional character, and remains well under the 30-word limit.
The response correctly supplies a fictional character using the required "name" and "age" keys, with valid JSON syntax and no surrounding commentary. Its concise form also satisfies the word limit without unnecessary material. A minor weakness is that the character description is minimal beyond the two required fields, offering no additional fictional context; however, the task did not request such context, and adding it could have been unnecessary. Overall, the response follows both the explicit format and content requirements precisely.
All three programmatic constraints pass: the output is valid JSON, contains exactly the keys name and age, and stays well under 30 words. It has no code fences or commentary. The character, Luna Star aged 28, is a generic placeholder, which keeps the content adequate rather than distinctive.
The response returns a valid JSON object with exactly the required keys, name and age, and no code fences or commentary, so the formatting instructions are followed. It stays comfortably within the word limit. The main weakness is that the character is generic: the name and age are unremarkable placeholders with no further detail, so the content is adequate rather than distinctive. The task requirements are met cleanly, though the answer does only the minimum requested.
DeepSeek-R1-0528-Qwen3-8B gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid JSON, contains exactly the required "name" and "age" keys, describes a fictional character, and remains well under the 30-word limit. It uses raw JSON without surrounding commentary or code fences.
The response directly satisfies the requested format by providing a raw JSON object with the required keys and plausible fictional character details. Its concise presentation stays comfortably within the word limit and avoids extra commentary. The response does not provide characterization beyond a name and age, but that is not a weakness relative to the task, which requested only those fields. No substantive constraint is omitted or violated, and the values are clear and correctly typed for the requested object.
The response is valid JSON with exactly the keys name and age, a plausible integer age, and is far under 30 words. All constraints pass, and the content is adequate but generic.
The response meets every stated constraint: it is valid JSON, contains exactly the keys name and age, and stays well under the thirty-word limit. The character name, Zephyr Stardust, is a fitting invented name and the age is a plausible integer. Its weakness is that it is very generic and offers little characterization beyond the two required fields, though the task did not request more. The output is raw JSON without fences or commentary, as instructed. Overall it fully fulfils the request with minimal content.
EXAONE-3.5-7.8B-Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response contains the intended name and age fields and stays under 30 words, but it is enclosed in Markdown code fences, making it invalid JSON and violating the raw-JSON-only requirement.
The response does provide a fictional character with a name and numeric age, and its content remains well below the word limit. However, the surrounding Markdown code fences prevent the output from being parsed as raw JSON, causing both JSON validity and the required output-format constraint to fail. The object’s keys are otherwise correctly named and ordered, so the failure is concentrated in the presentation format rather than the character data itself. The response therefore only partially satisfies the task.
The response wraps the object in a markdown json code fence, violating the explicit raw-only instruction. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as failed, leaving only the max_words constraint passed. The keys name and age are present and the content is a plausible fictional character, but the verdict fixes this in the wrong band.
The response attempts the requested task: it supplies a fictional character with both a name and an age field, and stays within the word limit. Its main weakness is formatting. It places the object inside a markdown code fence despite the instruction to output raw JSON only, which the programmatic checks treat as a failure of both validity and key structure. Only the length constraint is satisfied.
Falcon2 11B gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response stays within the 30-word limit, but it includes commentary before and after the object, making the overall output invalid JSON and failing the raw-JSON-only requirement. Consequently, the required key constraint also fails programmatically.
The response does provide a fictional character with the requested name and age fields, and its total length is within the stated limit. However, the surrounding sentence and trailing punctuation mean the complete output is not valid raw JSON. This also prevents it from satisfying the required JSON structure as evaluated. The main weakness is failure to output only the object itself; removing the introductory and concluding text would have addressed the central formatting problem while preserving the character data.
The response contains a valid JSON object with keys name and age, but prefaces it with commentary, violating the raw-JSON-only requirement. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as failed, so the response falls in the failing band. Word count is within the 30-word limit.
The response supplies the correct keys, name and age, inside a JSON object with plausible values, and it stays within the 30-word limit. Its main failure is that it opens with a sentence of commentary before the JSON, which the task explicitly forbade. Because the output as a whole is not valid JSON, the json_valid and json_keys checks both fail under the programmatic verdict. The response attempts the core task but breaks the output-format constraint, so it satisfies only the length limit.
Falcon3 1B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response stays within the 30-word limit, but it fails the raw-JSON requirement because it includes Markdown code fences. Consequently, the JSON-validity and key-check constraints both fail under the supplied verdict.
The response does provide a plausible fictional character with the requested name and age fields, and it remains concise enough to satisfy the word-count constraint. However, it encloses the object in Markdown code fences and includes surrounding formatting rather than returning raw JSON only. This makes the submitted text invalid as a directly parseable JSON response and causes the key-related checker to fail as well. The central content is therefore present, but the explicit output-format requirement is not met.
The response wraps the JSON in markdown code fences, violating the explicit raw-JSON-only instruction. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as failed, so the response violates two of three constraints. Only the word limit is satisfied. The content itself is a plausible name and age pair, but the format failure is decisive.
The response supplies a plausible fictional character with name and age fields and stays well within the word limit. Its main weakness is formatting: it wraps the object in a markdown code fence despite the instruction to output raw JSON only with no code fences. The programmatic checks report that the output fails both the JSON validity and the key-set constraints, so the response does not meet the core requirement of the task even though its underlying content is reasonable and concise.
Gemma 3n E4B IT gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response stays within the 30-word limit and attempts to provide the requested name and age, but it wraps the object in Markdown fences and includes nonstandard underscore characters, causing JSON validity and key checks to fail.
The response makes a clear attempt to represent a fictional character with a name and numeric age, and its content is well below the word limit. However, it violates the required raw-JSON format by enclosing the object in code fences. The visible underscore characters before the keys also make the content invalid JSON and prevent the required key structure from passing. Consequently, only the length constraint is satisfied, while both the validity and exact-key constraints fail.
The response wraps the object in markdown code fences, which the task forbade, so json_valid fails as a strict parse. The keys name and age are correct and the content is short, but the programmatic verdict marks both json_valid and json_keys as failed, and the response violates the explicit raw-only instruction. Most constraints are failed, so the score sits in the low band.
The response supplies a fictional character with the requested keys, name and age, and keeps the content well under the 30-word limit. Its main weakness is formatting: it wraps the object in markdown code fences despite the explicit instruction to output raw JSON only. The programmatic checks flag the response as failing both the JSON validity and key-structure constraints, so the reply does not meet the task as specified even though the underlying content is simple and appropriate.
Gemma3 1B IT gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response includes the intended name and age and stays under 30 words, but it violates the raw-JSON requirement by surrounding the object with markdown code fences. Consequently, it is not valid JSON as submitted and fails the required JSON constraint.
The response does provide a plausible fictional character with both required fields and remains within the word limit. However, the markdown code fences and language label make the complete output invalid as raw JSON, which also causes failure of the JSON-validity requirement. The object’s internal keys are otherwise appropriately named, but the enclosing formatting is a decisive hard-constraint violation for this task. The response would satisfy the task by returning only the JSON object without any surrounding fences or commentary.
The response wraps the JSON in markdown code fences, violating the raw-JSON-only instruction. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as failed, so the content does not parse as valid JSON as required. Only the word limit is satisfied, with the keys themselves correct in content but not in a valid raw form.
The response attempts the requested task by providing an object with both required keys, name and age, populated with a plausible fictional character. It stays well within the 30-word limit. However, it wraps the output in markdown code fences, which the prompt explicitly forbade, and the programmatic checks report that the output fails JSON validity and key matching. The structure is right in intent, but the delivery violates the core formatting constraint, so the response does not fully meet the task.
GLM-4.7-Flash gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response supplies a fictional name and age and stays within the 30-word limit. However, the surrounding Markdown code fences make the output invalid raw JSON and cause the required JSON validity and key constraints to fail under the programmatic verdict.
The response does provide a plausible fictional character with both requested fields and remains well below the word limit. Its main weakness is format compliance: it wraps the object in Markdown code fences, despite the explicit requirement for raw JSON only. As a result, the output is not directly parseable as JSON and does not satisfy the required structural checks, even though the intended object contains the correct key names. The content is otherwise concise and on topic.
The response wraps the JSON in markdown code fences, violating the explicit raw-JSON-only instruction. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as failed, though the object itself contains name and age keys with plausible values. Only the word-count constraint passes, so most constraints are violated.
The response supplies a JSON object with the requested name and age keys and a plausible fictional character, and it stays well within the thirty-word limit. Its main weakness is that it places the object inside a markdown code fence, which breaks the instruction to output raw JSON only with no code fences. The programmatic checks record the JSON validity and key-set constraints as failed, so the response satisfies only the length requirement. The content itself is simple and on-topic, but the formatting failure is decisive under the stated constraints.
Granite3.3 2B gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid raw JSON, contains exactly the required "name" and "age" keys, describes a fictional character, and is well under the 30-word limit.
The response correctly supplies a fictional character with a name and age in a minimal JSON object. Its formatting is appropriate for machine parsing: there are no code fences, surrounding comments, or extra keys, and all stated constraints pass. The age is represented as a JSON string rather than a numeric value, but the task does not require a particular JSON type for age, so this is not a substantive violation. No material weakness is evident relative to the specified requirements.
The response is valid JSON with exactly the keys "name" and "age", has no code fences or commentary, and is well under 30 words. All programmatic constraints pass. The content is generic: a stock fantasy name and an age given as a string rather than a number.
The response returns valid JSON with exactly the two required keys, name and age, and stays well within the 30-word limit. It contains no code fences or commentary, matching the raw-output instruction. The character details are generic: the name is a stock fantasy-style name, and the age is supplied as a string rather than a number, which a stricter reading of the task might not expect. The content is adequate for a minimal task.
Hermes3 3B Llama3.2 gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid JSON, contains exactly the required "name" and "age" keys, describes a fictional character, and remains well under the 30-word limit.
The response satisfies all explicit task requirements. It uses raw JSON without surrounding commentary or code fences, includes exactly the requested keys, and provides a fictional name and age. Its compact presentation also stays comfortably within the maximum word count. The age is represented as a string rather than a numeric value, but the task does not require a particular JSON type for age, so this does not constitute a violation. The only minor content limitation is that the unusual age wording is less conventional than a simple numeral, while still remaining acceptable for the stated constraints.
Output is valid JSON with exactly the name and age keys, is well under 30 words, and has no fences or commentary. The name is fitting. The age value 'nine hundred 12' is an odd, ambiguous string, but every constraint is met.
The response is valid JSON containing exactly the required keys, name and age, and stays within the word limit. The character name Lancre Blackspore is evocative and fits a fictional persona. The weakness is the age value, which is written as a garbled phrase with an unexplained trailing number, making it unclear whether the character is nine hundred twelve years old or something else. Output is otherwise clean, with no code fences or commentary added around the object.
Internlm2 1.8B Chat V2.5 gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response conveys a fictional name and age and stays under 30 words, satisfying the word limit. However, it includes Markdown code fences and therefore fails the raw-JSON requirement; the programmatic verdict also marks JSON validity and required-key constraints as failed.
The response has a relevant fictional character and presents both requested fields with plausible values. Its main weakness is formatting: the JSON object is enclosed in Markdown code fences, despite the explicit requirement for raw JSON only. This causes the response to fail the validity and key-structure checks in the supplied verdict, even though the visible object itself uses the requested names and remains within the word limit. The model therefore addresses the content but misses the required output form.
The response contains the correct keys and a valid-looking object, but wraps it in markdown code fences despite the explicit instruction for raw JSON only. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as failed, so the response falls in the wrong band. Word count passes, but most hard constraints are violated.
The response supplies a plausible fictional character with the two requested keys, name and age, and stays within the word limit. Its main weakness is formatting: it wraps the object in a markdown json code fence, which violates the explicit instruction to output raw JSON only with no code fences. Because the programmatic checker reports that the output failed both the JSON validity and the key-set constraints, the response does not satisfy the core requirements of the task despite its otherwise sensible content.
Llama2 13B Chat gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response stays within 30 words and includes the requested fictional name and age, but the surrounding commentary means the complete output is not valid raw JSON and does not satisfy the required exact object format.
The response does provide a plausible fictional character and keeps the total output within the word limit. However, it begins with explanatory prose and places the object in a multi-line presentation rather than returning raw JSON only. Because the complete output includes text outside the JSON object, it fails JSON validity and the requested output-format constraint, despite containing the correct keys and otherwise reasonable values.
The response includes a preamble sentence before the JSON, violating the raw-JSON-only instruction, so json_valid fails. The JSON object itself has the correct keys and a fitting age, and total length is within 30 words. Two of three constraints failed per the programmatic verdict, placing it in the lowest band.
The response supplies a JSON object with the requested keys, name and age, describing a fictional character, and it stays within the word limit. Its main weakness is that it opens with an introductory sentence restating the task, which breaks the explicit requirement to output raw JSON only with no commentary before or after. The programmatic checks confirm that the output fails both the JSON validity and key-structure constraints because the surrounding prose makes the whole reply invalid JSON. The attempt at the content is reasonable, but the formatting violation is decisive for this instruction-following item.
Magistral Small (2506) gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response includes the requested character data and stays under 30 words, but the Markdown code fences make it invalid raw JSON and prevent the required top-level key structure from being satisfied according to the verdict.
The response does provide a plausible fictional character name and age, and it remains within the specified word limit. However, it wraps the object in Markdown code fences, violating the explicit raw-JSON-only requirement. This causes the JSON-validity and required-keys checks to fail, despite the apparent object content being structurally appropriate when viewed without the fences. The main weakness is therefore formatting rather than the selected fields or their values.
The response wraps the JSON in a markdown code fence despite the instruction to output raw JSON only. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as failed, so the fenced output is not parseable as raw JSON. Only the word limit is satisfied, and the content itself (name and age keys with a fictional character) is appropriate but does not rescue the failed hard constraints.
The response supplies a fictional character with the two requested keys, name and age, and it stays well under the thirty-word limit. Its main weakness is that it is enclosed in a markdown code fence, which violates the explicit instruction to output raw JSON with no code fences. Because the fence makes the output invalid as a bare JSON document, the validity and key-set checks both fail. The model appears to have understood the content requirements but did not follow the formatting requirement that the task emphasised, so the output cannot be consumed directly by a parser.
Ministral 3 14B Instruct (2512) gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response stays within 30 words, but it fails JSON validity because it includes a trailing fenced code block after the object. It also therefore does not provide the required raw JSON-only output and fails the specified key constraint according to the programmatic verdict.
The response does provide a fictional character with a name and numeric age, and the character data itself is concise and suitable for the task. However, it appends a markdown code-fence fragment after the JSON object, violating the raw-JSON-only requirement and making the complete output invalid JSON. The programmatic verdict also marks both JSON validity and the required key constraint as failed, leaving only the word-count constraint satisfied.
The response contains a valid-looking JSON object with name and age keys, but it is followed by a code fence (an empty json fence), violating the raw-JSON-only instruction. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as failed, so most constraints are violated despite the word limit being met.
The response supplies the requested keys, name and age, with plausible fictional values, and stays well under the thirty-word limit. Its main weakness is that it wraps the output in markdown code fences and appends an extra empty fence after the object, so the whole reply does not parse as valid JSON and violates the explicit instruction to output raw JSON only. The programmatic checks for JSON validity and exact keys therefore fail, and the response only satisfies the length constraint.
Ministral 3 3B Instruct 2512 gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response stays within 30 words, but it violates the raw-JSON-only requirement by enclosing the object in Markdown code fences. Consequently, the supplied checker marks both JSON validity and the required-key constraint as failed.
The response does provide a fictional character with a plausible name and numeric age, and it remains concise enough to satisfy the word-limit constraint. However, the output is wrapped in a ```json code fence and therefore is not raw JSON as requested. That formatting causes the programmatic JSON-validity and key checks to fail, despite the object itself containing the intended fields. The response would have met the task by removing the opening and closing fence markers while preserving the object content.
The response wraps the JSON in markdown code fences, violating the explicit raw-JSON-only instruction. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as failed, since the fenced text is not parseable as raw JSON. Only the word-count limit is met. The content itself (name and age keys with plausible values) addresses the topic, so it is not an empty or off-topic reply.
The response supplies a JSON object with the requested keys, name and age, and the values are plausible for a fictional character. Its main weakness is that it wraps the object in a markdown code fence, which the prompt explicitly prohibited. Because of this, the output fails the raw-JSON validity check and is not usable as-is by a parser. The response stays within the 30-word limit, so that single constraint is satisfied. Overall the model attempted the task but failed the format requirements that the prompt stressed.
Phi3 14B Medium 128K Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response stays under 30 words, but it is not raw JSON because it uses code fences and whitespace presentation, and its key is "e" rather than the required "age". Only the length constraint passes.
The response does provide a fictional character name and a plausible numeric age value, showing that it attempted the requested structure and stayed within the length limit. However, it fails the required output format by enclosing the content in code fences, and it uses "e" instead of the mandatory "age" key. Consequently, it is not valid JSON in the required raw form and does not contain the specified key set. The missing required key is the main substantive defect, while the fencing is an additional hard-format violation.
The programmatic verdict fails json_valid and json_keys. The response wraps the JSON in markdown code fences, which the task forbade, and uses the key "e" instead of "age", so the keys do not match. Only the word limit is met, and the content is a near miss rather than a correct answer.
The response attempts the requested task by producing a fictional character with a name and a numeric age-like value, and it stays well within the thirty-word limit. Its main weakness is that the second key is spelled "e" rather than "age", so the required key set is not produced. The response also wraps the output in markdown code fences despite the explicit instruction to output raw JSON only. These two failures mean the output does not satisfy the core structural requirements of the task.
Qwen 0.5B Chat V1.5 gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response stays within 30 words and presents the intended character data, but it uses Markdown code fences, making the result invalid raw JSON and violating the required exact key/output format.
The response does provide a fictional character name and age, and its content is concise enough to satisfy the word-limit constraint. However, the surrounding Markdown code fences mean the complete output is not valid raw JSON, which is a central explicit requirement. Because the parser cannot accept the fenced form as the requested JSON object, the response also fails the JSON-validity and exact-format checks despite containing the expected two keys inside the fence.
The response wraps the JSON in markdown code fences, which the task explicitly forbade. json_valid fails because the fenced text is not raw parseable JSON, and json_keys fails for the same reason. Only the max_words constraint passes. Content itself has the correct name and age keys with plausible values.
The response supplies a JSON object with the requested keys, name and age, and the content is short enough to satisfy the word limit. Its main weakness is that it wraps the output in a markdown code fence despite the explicit instruction to output raw JSON only with no code fences. Because the fence makes the whole reply invalid as parseable JSON, the response fails both the validity and key-checking constraints. The formatting failure outweighs the otherwise correct structure of the object.
Qwen2 0.5B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response describes a fictional character and stays under 30 words, satisfying the word-count constraint. However, it wraps the object in Markdown fences, so it is not raw valid JSON and does not satisfy the required key constraint programmatically.
The response provides the requested fictional character information, using the keys “name” and “age” with plausible values, and it remains well within the word limit. Its main weakness is formatting: the JSON object is enclosed in a Markdown code fence and therefore is not raw JSON as required. The programmatic checks consequently mark both JSON validity and the exact key requirement as failed, despite the content inside the fence being structurally appropriate. The response attempts the intended data representation but misses the explicit output-format requirement.
The response wraps the JSON in markdown code fences, violating the explicit raw-JSON-only instruction. The json_valid check fails because the fenced text is not parseable as raw JSON, and json_keys fails for the same reason. Only the max_words constraint passes. The content has the correct keys, but most constraints are violated.
The response addresses the task topic by producing a JSON object with the requested keys, name and age, and a plausible fictional character. Its main weakness is that it wraps the output in markdown code fences, which the prompt explicitly forbade. As a result the output fails the raw-JSON validity check and the key-set check under the programmatic verdict, even though the word limit is respected. The model followed the content request but not the formatting constraint that the task stated most directly.
Qwen2.5 1.5B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response contains the intended name and age and stays under 30 words, but code fences make it invalid raw JSON, and the key constraint consequently fails under the programmatic verdict.
The response does provide a fictional character with the requested name and age fields, and its content remains concise. However, it violates the explicit raw-JSON-only requirement by surrounding the object with Markdown code fences. The programmatic checks therefore mark JSON validity and the required key structure as failed, while only the word-count constraint passes. The response is close in substance but does not satisfy the required output format, which is essential for machine-readable JSON tasks.
The response is valid JSON with the correct keys and is under 30 words, but it is wrapped in markdown code fences, which the task explicitly forbade. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as fail, so the response fails two of three constraints, placing it in the nearly-all-failed band.
The response supplies a fictional character with the requested keys, name and age, and the content itself is well-formed and short enough to meet the word limit. Its main weakness is that it is wrapped in a markdown code fence, violating the explicit instruction to output raw JSON only with no code fences. The programmatic checks report that the output fails both the JSON validity and key-matching constraints, so the fence formatting is the decisive defect. The model clearly understood the task content but did not follow the output-format requirement.
Qwen2.5 Coder 1.5B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response supplies the intended name and age, and stays under 30 words. However, the code fences make it invalid raw JSON, and the required key check therefore fails.
The response includes a plausible fictional character name and a numeric age, while remaining comfortably within the word limit. Its main weakness is the use of Markdown code fences around the object, despite the explicit requirement for raw JSON only. That formatting causes the JSON-validity constraint to fail and also means the required key structure is not recognized by the checker. The content is otherwise on topic and concise, but it does not satisfy the strict output-format requirements.
The response wraps the JSON in markdown code fences, violating the raw-JSON-only requirement. The programmatic verdict marks json_valid and json_keys as failed, so the fenced output does not parse as valid JSON. The content itself (name and age keys, under 30 words) is the only part that meets the constraints, and max_words passes.
The response supplies an object with the requested name and age keys and stays well under the thirty-word limit. Its main failure is wrapping the object in a markdown code fence, which the prompt explicitly forbade. Because the fence surrounds the payload, the output is not parseable as bare JSON, so the validity and key checks fail under the programmatic verdict. The character content is otherwise simple and acceptable, but the formatting violation dominates the outcome for this instruction-following item.
Stable Code 3B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response stays within 30 words, but it is not raw JSON because it includes explanatory text and code fences. Consequently, the JSON-validity and required-output-format constraints fail, while only the word-limit constraint passes.
The response does identify a fictional character and supplies the requested name and age in a recognizable JSON snippet. However, it surrounds that snippet with commentary and Markdown code fences, violating the requirement for raw JSON only. Because the extra text makes the complete output invalid JSON, the response also fails the JSON-validity constraint. The content itself is otherwise appropriate and concise, and it remains below the maximum word limit. The main weakness is failure to provide the object as the entire response with no surrounding material.
The response adds a preamble sentence and wraps the JSON in a markdown code fence, violating the raw-JSON-only instruction. The JSON itself has the correct keys and is valid, but the programmatic verdicts for json_valid and json_keys both failed, so the response falls in the nearly-all-failed band. Word limit is met.
The response supplies a JSON object with the required keys, name and age, and a plausible fictional character with a valid numeric age. Its main weakness is that it ignores the explicit formatting requirement: it opens with an introductory sentence and wraps the object in a markdown code fence, so the output is not raw JSON as instructed. The programmatic checks for validity and key matching failed on the full response, which is why the score is low despite the sensible content. It does stay within the 30-word limit.
Aya 8B 23 gap 1
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid JSON, uses exactly the required keys, and stays within 30 words. However, it identifies Elon Musk, a real person, rather than a fictional character as requested.
The response correctly provides a compact JSON object with the required name and age keys, and it satisfies the structural and length constraints. Its main weakness is semantic: Elon Musk is a real public figure, so the result does not describe a fictional character. The age value also presents a potentially time-dependent claim, though the more direct issue is the failure to follow the fictional-character requirement. The response otherwise remains on topic and includes no extra commentary or formatting violations.
All three programmatic constraints pass: the output is valid JSON with exactly the keys name and age, and it is well under 30 words. However, the name 'Elon Musk' is a real public figure, not the fictional character the prompt requested, so the evident intent is missed.
The response meets every formal requirement: it is raw JSON with exactly the keys name and age, and it stays well within the word limit. Its weakness is content. The prompt asked for a fictional character, but the response supplies a real, identifiable person, so the output misses the task's evident intent even though the structure is correct. The age value is also unsupported by any fictional context, which makes the entry less useful as a character description.
Aya Expanse 32B gap 1
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid raw JSON, contains exactly the required "name" and "age" keys, describes a fictional character, and uses fewer than 30 words. It includes no surrounding commentary or code fences.
The response directly satisfies every stated constraint. It provides a plausible fictional character through the name Amelia Wright and assigns an age of 28. The JSON is syntactically valid, uses exactly the requested keys, and remains well below the 30-word limit. Its main strength is precise compliance without unnecessary text. There is no substantive weakness relative to the task; the brief object supplies all requested information and avoids extra fields, formatting, or commentary.
All three programmatic constraints pass: the output is valid JSON, contains exactly the keys name and age, and is well under 30 words. The character is fictional and content is purposeful. Output is raw JSON with no code fences or commentary, as requested.
The response returns a valid JSON object with the two required keys, name and age, describing a fictional character named Amelia Wright aged 28. It contains no code fences or surrounding commentary, and stays far below the 30-word limit, so every stated constraint is met. The weakness is minimal: the response is very brief and offers no additional character detail, so it fulfils the request in the most bare form possible. Within the constraints, the content is adequate and appropriately concise.
Aya Expanse 8B gap 1
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid raw JSON, contains exactly the required "name" and "age" keys, describes a fictional character, and stays within the 30-word limit.
The response fully satisfies the task requirements. Its strength is precise compliance: it presents a fictional character with a clear name and numeric age, uses valid JSON syntax, includes exactly the requested keys, and avoids any surrounding commentary or code fencing. There is no substantive weakness in relation to the stated constraints. The formatting is concise and suitable for direct parsing, while the output remains comfortably below the maximum word limit. The model therefore meets both the structural and content expectations without unnecessary additions.
All three programmatic constraints pass: the output is valid JSON, contains exactly the keys name and age, and stays well under 30 words. The content is a purposeful fictional character with a plausible name and age, delivered without code fences or commentary.
The response returns a valid JSON object with exactly the two requested keys, name and age, and supplies a plausible fictional character with a full name and an adult age. It contains no code fences, preamble, or trailing commentary, and it stays well within the thirty-word limit. The output is minimal and accurate to the instruction. Its main limitation is that the character is generic and offers no additional detail beyond the two required fields, which is consistent with the task's narrow scope rather than a flaw in execution.
Codegeex4 9B All gap 1
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid raw JSON, contains exactly the required "name" and "age" keys, describes a fictional character, and is well under the 30-word limit.
The response directly satisfies the requested structure by providing a JSON object with exactly the two required keys. It also uses a recognizable fictional placeholder name and a numeric age, while remaining concise and free of surrounding commentary or code fences. The main limitation is that “John Doe” is generic rather than a distinctly developed fictional character, but the task only required a character description through name and age. No required constraint is violated, and the output is suitable for direct parsing.
All three constraints pass: the output is valid JSON, contains exactly the keys "name" and "age", and is well under 30 words. No code fences or commentary. The character is generic ("John Doe", 30), which is adequate but unremarkable for a fictional character request.
The response returns a single compact JSON object with the required keys name and age, with no code fences or surrounding commentary, and stays far below the word limit. Every stated constraint is satisfied. The content is minimal and generic: the name John Doe is a placeholder-style default rather than a distinctive fictional character, so it meets the letter of the task without adding much creative substance. Both the format and the length requirements are handled cleanly.
Codellama 34B Instruct gap 1
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid raw JSON, contains exactly the required "name" and "age" keys, describes a fictional character, and remains well under the 30-word limit.
The response correctly provides a fictional character using the two required keys, with a string name and numeric age. It is formatted as raw JSON without code fences or surrounding commentary, directly satisfying the output-format requirement. The content is minimal but adequate for the task, and the response stays comfortably within the word limit. No substantive weakness is evident under the stated constraints; the chosen character details are clear and valid.
All three programmatic constraints pass: the output is valid JSON, contains exactly the keys name and age, and stays well under 30 words. The character is fictional and the content is minimal but purposeful. Formatting is multi-line raw JSON with no code fences or commentary, as requested.
The response returns a valid JSON object with exactly the two required keys, name and age, populated with a plausible fictional character. It contains no code fences, prose, or commentary, and stays well within the word limit. The main weakness is that the content is minimal: the character has only a name and an age, with no further detail, which is acceptable for the task as specified but leaves little room for a richer characterization. Overall the response fully meets the stated instructions.
Codellama 7B Instruct gap 1
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid JSON, contains exactly the required "name" and "age" keys, describes a fictional character, and remains well below the 30-word limit.
The response fully satisfies the requested output format and content. It provides a fictional character with a name and numeric age, uses valid raw JSON syntax, and includes no surrounding commentary or code fences. The two required keys appear exactly as specified, and the compact formatting stays comfortably within the word limit. There are no observed content or constraint violations. Its only limitation is that the character description is minimal, but the task required only those two fields, so this brevity is appropriate rather than a substantive weakness.
All three programmatic constraints pass: the output parses as valid JSON, contains exactly the keys name and age, and stays well under 30 words. Content is a minimal, purposeful fictional character with a name and numeric age, and there is no code fence or commentary around the object.
The response returns a bare JSON object with the required name and age keys, satisfying every stated constraint including the word limit and the no-fences, no-commentary requirement. The character itself is generic, with a common name and a round age, so the content is adequate rather than distinctive. The output is also formatted across multiple lines, which is harmless here since the task did not forbid whitespace. Overall the task is fully met with no violations observed.
Cogito 8B V1 Preview Llama gap 1
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid raw JSON, contains exactly the required "name" and "age" keys, describes a fictional character, and remains well below the 30-word limit.
The response precisely follows the requested output format by providing a raw JSON object with the two required keys and no surrounding commentary. It gives a plausible fictional name and a numeric age, satisfying the content requirement concisely. Its only limitation is that the character is described minimally, with no additional characterization beyond the name and age; however, the task explicitly requested only those fields, so this is not a substantive deficiency. The JSON syntax and key set are both correct.
The response is raw JSON with exactly the keys "name" and "age", no code fences or commentary, and well under 30 words. All three programmatic constraints pass. The content is a plausible fictional character with a fitting name and integer age, so it is purposeful rather than merely minimal.
The response meets every stated constraint: it is valid JSON, contains exactly the required keys name and age, and emits no code fences or surrounding commentary. It is also concise, well within the word limit. The character it describes, a young adult with a whimsical fantasy-style name and an integer age, fits the request for a fictional character. Its main limitation is that it offers only two fields, so the character is sketched minimally with no further detail. Within the brief's scope, however, the output is accurate and complete, and no constraint is violated or strained.
Command R7B (12-2024) gap 1
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The response is valid raw JSON, contains exactly the required keys "name" and "age", describes a character with a name and age, and remains well under the 30-word limit.
The response fulfills the requested structure precisely: it supplies the two required fields, uses a plausible character name, and gives a numeric age. Its raw JSON formatting contains no surrounding commentary or code fences, and its length is comfortably within the stated limit. The content is necessarily minimal because the task requests only a name and age; it does not provide additional fictional characterization, but no such detail was required. No constraint is violated, and the object is directly usable as requested.
All three constraints pass: the output is valid JSON, contains exactly the keys name and age, and is well under 30 words. Content is a plausible fictional character with a string name and numeric age. Formatting is multi-line with indentation, which the prompt did not forbid, and no code fences or commentary are present.
The response returns a valid JSON object with exactly the required keys, name and age, and supplies a plausible fictional character with a string name and numeric age. It stays comfortably within the thirty-word limit and avoids code fences and commentary as instructed. Its main weakness is that the character is generic, with a common name and an unremarkable age, so it does little beyond meeting the literal requirements. The indented multi-line layout is harmless but adds nothing, and the answer is correct without being distinctive.
The other 198 models
Their judges were closer together. Their scores are listed here; open the model's page for the full answer.
Withheld
These models are kept out of the ranking, so none of their scores or reasons are shown:
The judge room names the judges and shows where they disagree most.