coding-008: both judges
A public question in Coding, battery v1. It starts: “Write a function that merges overlapping or touching integer intervals. Each interval is `[a, b]` with `a <= b`. Two intervals merge if they…” Read the question and every model's answer.
228 models judged; 8 disputed (judges 3 or more points apart). The gap is the distance between the two judges' scores. Models are ordered by that gap, widest first.
Openthinker 7B V2 gap 4, disputed
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function is correct and passed all 10 tests: it sorts by start, merges overlapping or touching intervals, preserves the maximum end, and handles empty input. However, the response violates the required output shape by including extensive reasoning and explanation instead of only one Python code block.
The response provides a clean, idiomatic interval-merging implementation that correctly handles unsorted input, touching boundaries, nested intervals, and empty lists. Its main weakness is instruction compliance: it includes a long internal reasoning trace, explanatory prose, headings, and complexity discussion despite the explicit requirement to return only one code block. The implementation also mutates interval lists reused from the sorted input, which was not exposed by the tests but could be undesirable for callers expecting inputs to remain unchanged.
Programmatic verdict is 10/10 tests passed, placing the response in the 7-10 band. The code is correct and idiomatic, but the response violates the explicit instruction to return only one code block with no explanation: it includes a visible think block, a prose approach section, and an explanation. Per rubric band rules, this format violation caps quality, so the score is placed at the lower end of the band.
The response implements a correct sort-then-sweep merge that handles touching intervals, empty input, and nested intervals, and all tests passed. Its main weakness is format: despite the instruction to return only one Python code block with no explanation, it includes a visible reasoning section, a multi-part prose approach, and a lengthy explanation after the code. The code itself is clean and concise, but the extra material ignores the requested output shape.
Aya Expanse 32B gap 3, disputed
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passed all 10 tests, sorts intervals by start, merges overlapping and touching intervals using `<=`, handles empty input, and returns the required merged structure in a single Python code block.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic implementation that directly satisfies the requested signature and output format. It correctly handles unsorted input, empty input, overlap, and endpoint touching, as demonstrated by the complete test result. The implementation mutates the input list and reuses interval sublists while building the result, which could matter to callers expecting non-mutating behavior, but that behavior was not required by the task and did not affect the tests. No unnecessary explanation or extra code was included.
All 10 tests pass and the algorithm is correct: sort by start, then merge when current[0] <= last[1]. Touching intervals merge as required, and output is one code block with no prose. However, it sorts the caller's list in place and mutates the inner interval lists during merging, which the tests did not exercise.
The response implements the standard sort-then-sweep merge, correctly handling touching intervals such as [1, 3] and [3, 5], and passes every test. Its main weakness is that it mutates the caller's input: the list is sorted in place and the returned intervals alias the original inner lists, so the argument is altered as a side effect. Copying the intervals before sorting would avoid this. The output is a single code block with no extra prose, as requested.
Falcon3 7B Instruct gap 3, disputed
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests, sorts intervals by start, merges both overlapping and touching ranges using the correct boundary comparison, handles empty input, and returns the required merged structure in a single Python code block.
The response correctly implements the required interval merge behavior. It sorts the input, then combines an interval whenever its start is no greater than the current merged end, which correctly handles both overlap and touching endpoints. It also handles an empty list and follows the requested output shape with exactly one code block and no explanation. A minor implementation consideration is that it sorts and mutates the supplied list and may reuse interval sublists, but the task does not require preserving the input, and this does not detract from correctness under the stated requirements.
All 10 tests pass and the sweep-line logic correctly merges touching intervals using a strict > comparison. The function sorts the caller's list in place and mutates the inner interval lists via merged[-1][1] assignment, so input data is altered as a side effect. Output is a single code block with no extra prose.
The response implements the standard sort-and-sweep approach, correctly treating touching intervals such as [1, 3] and [3, 5] as mergeable and handling the empty-input case. Its main weakness is side effects: it sorts the caller's list in place and writes into the original interval sublists, so passing data in alters it. Copying the intervals before merging would avoid this. The output follows the single-code-block instruction with no explanation.
Phi4 Mini Reasoning 3.8B gap 3, disputed
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The implementation passes all 10 tests and correctly sorts, merges overlapping or touching intervals, handles empty input, and preserves maximum endpoints. However, the response violates the required output shape by including extensive reasoning and explanation instead of only one Python code block.
The response provides a correct and reasonably idiomatic interval-merging implementation, including the required touching-interval condition and empty-input handling. Its main weakness is instruction compliance: it includes visible internal reasoning, explanatory prose, headings, and a complexity discussion despite the request for only one Python code block. The function also mutates interval lists reused from the sorted input, which is not prohibited but could be undesirable for callers. The implementation itself is consistent with the supplied passing test verdict.
All 10 tests passed per the programmatic verdict, so the response falls in the 7-10 band. However, the output violates the explicit instruction to return only one code block with no explanation: it includes a visible think block, a long prose explanation with headers, and a code block. Shape compliance drops it to the lower end of the band.
The response implements a correct sort-then-sweep merge that handles touching intervals, empty input, and unsorted input, and the code passes all tests. Its main weakness is that it ignores the output-shape instruction: it exposes a reasoning block and a lengthy explanation with headings alongside the code, despite the request for only one code block with no explanation. The merge logic also mutates the caller's inner lists via the sorted copy, which is a minor latent side effect that the tests did not exercise.
Qwen2.5 1.5B Instruct gap 3, disputed
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests, sorts intervals by start, merges overlapping and touching ranges using the correct strict comparison, and returns sorted merged intervals in the requested single Python code block.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic implementation that correctly handles unsorted input and merges both overlapping and endpoint-touching intervals. It follows the requested output shape by returning exactly one Python code block containing only the function. The implementation mutates the input list and the interval sublists in place, which could be undesirable if callers expect their input to remain unchanged, but that behavior was not prohibited by the task and did not affect the test results.
All 10 tests pass and the merge logic correctly treats touching intervals as overlapping via the strict `<` comparison. However, it sorts the caller's list in place and mutates the inner interval lists (`merged[-1][1] = ...`), so the input is altered as a side effect. The code is otherwise short and idiomatic.
The response implements the standard sort-then-sweep approach. Its comparison `merged[-1][1] < interval[0]` correctly merges touching intervals such as [1, 3] and [3, 5], and all programmatic tests pass. The main weakness is that it mutates the caller's input: it sorts the list it receives and writes into the existing inner lists when extending a merged interval. A version that copies the intervals first would avoid this latent side effect, which the tests do not exercise.
Qwen2.5-14B-Instruct gap 3, disputed
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests, sorts unsorted intervals, merges overlapping and integer-touching ranges, handles empty input, and returns the required structure in one Python code block. Its condition using `interval[0] - 1` correctly captures touching integer endpoints.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic implementation that sorts intervals and extends the current merged endpoint correctly. It also handles empty input and integer intervals that touch at a boundary, satisfying the stated behavior. A minor design consideration is that it sorts the caller’s list in place and may mutate interval sublists during merging, although neither behavior violates the task’s explicit requirements or affected the tests. The output shape follows the instruction exactly, with one code block and no explanatory text.
All 10 tests pass and the response is a single code block with no explanation. The merge condition `merged[-1][1] < interval[0] - 1` also merges integer-adjacent intervals such as [1,3] and [4,5], which the task does not ask for. The function also sorts the input in place and mutates the caller's interval lists.
The response implements a standard sort-then-sweep merge that passes every supplied test and returns one code block as requested. Its main weakness is the merge condition, which uses a 'minus one' check that also joins integer-adjacent intervals like [1,3] and [4,5]. The task specified only overlap or shared endpoints, so this is a latent bug the tests did not exercise. The function also sorts the caller's list in place and reuses the input sublists, so the input is mutated as a side effect.
Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507 gap 3, disputed
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests, sorts unsorted intervals, merges both overlapping and touching ranges using the correct boundary condition, and handles empty input. It returns the requested structure in a single Python code block with no explanatory text outside it.
The response correctly implements the required interval merge behavior. It handles empty input, sorts intervals by start, and extends the current merged endpoint for overlapping or touching ranges. The implementation is concise and uses the requested signature and output format. One minor consideration is that it sorts the input list in place and reuses interval sublists, so callers could observe mutation of their input data; however, the task does not prohibit this, and the implementation satisfies the tested requirements.
All tests pass with a correct sort-and-sweep merge. The code uses <= so touching intervals merge, and it handles empty input. It calls intervals.sort() in place and mutates the caller's sublists via merged[-1][1], a latent side effect the tests did not exercise.
The response passes all tests with a concise sort-and-sweep approach. It handles unsorted input, empty input, and touching endpoints through the comparison current start <= last end. Its main weakness is that it sorts the caller's list in place and extends the input's sublists directly, so the caller's data is mutated as a side effect. Copying the intervals before sorting would avoid this. The reply follows the instruction to return a single code block with no explanation.
Sage-A1.5-Q4_K_M gap 3, disputed
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function sorts intervals by start, merges overlapping or adjacent integer ranges using `current[0] <= last[1] + 1`, handles empty input, and returns sorted merged intervals. It matches all 10 tests and obeys the requirement to provide exactly one Python code block with no explanation.
The response correctly implements the requested interval merge behavior. It sorts unsorted input, combines ranges that overlap or are adjacent in the integer domain, and handles an empty list without error. The use of a copied two-element list when merging avoids modifying the original interval’s endpoint structure in that branch. No substantive weakness is apparent: the output contains one code block, the function has the requested signature, and its concise implementation addresses the stated examples and edge behavior.
All 10 tests pass and the response is a single code block with no explanation. However, the merge condition `current[0] <= last[1] + 1` also merges integer-adjacent intervals such as [1,3] and [4,5], which the task does not ask for. The tests evidently did not exercise this case.
The response sorts by start and merges with a single linear pass, handling the empty input and the shared-endpoint example correctly. It follows the requested output shape of one code block with no commentary. Its weakness is the merge condition, which uses last end plus one and so also joins intervals that neither overlap nor touch, such as [1,3] and [4,5]. This is a latent correctness bug that the provided tests did not catch.
Codegemma 7B Instruct V1.1 gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
All 10 tests passed. The function sorts intervals, merges overlaps and equal-endpoint touching intervals using the correct strict separation check, and returns sorted results in one Python code block. It omits the requested list annotations and mutates the input list and interval sublists, though neither issue prevented the tested behavior.
The response correctly implements the central interval-merging logic: sorting establishes order, and the comparison merges both overlapping and touching ranges. It also follows the requested one-code-block output shape and passed every supplied test. A minor weakness is that it does not use the explicitly requested annotated signature, and it sorts and edits the caller’s input in place. Those side effects were not prohibited by the task and did not affect the programmatic tests, but copying the data would make the function safer for general use.
All ten tests pass. The sweep over sorted intervals merges when the next start is not greater than the current end, so touching intervals are handled. The code is concise and returns one code block. It sorts the caller's list in place and appends the original sublists, then mutates them when extending a merge.
The response passes all ten tests with a concise sweep over sorted intervals. Its merge condition correctly treats touching intervals as overlapping, and the output is a single code block with no extra prose, matching the requested shape. The main weakness is a side effect: it sorts the caller's list in place and appends the original sublists to the result, then mutates them when extending a merge. Callers reusing their input would see it altered, a latent bug the tests did not exercise. Copying each interval before merging would avoid this.
Codellama 7B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests and correctly sorts intervals, merges overlapping or touching ranges using `>=`, and returns the merged result. However, it does not follow the explicit output-shape instruction to provide one Python code block; it returns bare code instead.
The response correctly implements the core interval-merging algorithm. It sorts by start, compares each interval with the current result, and extends the endpoint when ranges overlap or touch. The implementation is concise and passes every supplied test. Its main weakness is instruction compliance: the task explicitly requested one Python code block, but the response provides un-fenced source text. It also sorts and modifies the input list and may reuse interval objects, although the task does not explicitly prohibit mutation.
All 10 tests pass per the programmatic verdict. The code sorts by start, then merges when the previous end is greater than or equal to the next start, correctly handling touching intervals like [1,3] and [3,5]. It returns a single code block with no extra prose, as requested. Minor weakness: it mutates the input list via in-place sort and appends original interval lists, so the result aliases input objects.
The response implements the standard sort-then-sweep approach. It sorts intervals by start and merges whenever the current interval begins at or before the running end, which correctly covers the touching case required by the task. The output shape matches the request: one Python code block containing only the function, with no explanation. Its main weakness is side effects: it sorts the caller's list in place and stores references to the original inner lists, so mutating the result can alter the input. A copy would avoid this. The code is short, idiomatic, and passes the full test set.
Cogito 14B V1 Preview Qwen gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests, correctly sorts intervals, merges overlapping or touching ranges with <=, and handles empty input. It follows the requirement to return one Python code block containing only the function. It mutates the input list and interval objects in place, an unrequested side effect that slightly reduces robustness.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic implementation that handles unsorted input, empty input, overlap, and touching boundaries correctly. Its sorting and max-endpoint update directly implement the required behavior, and the output shape follows the task’s formatting instruction. A weakness is that it sorts the caller’s list in place and reuses its interval objects, modifying the original data when merging. Although this does not affect the supplied tests or stated examples, avoiding those side effects would make the function more generally robust.
All 10 tests pass and the merge logic is correct, including touching intervals via the <= comparison. However, the code sorts the caller's list in place and mutates the original inner lists through merged[-1][1] assignment, a side effect the tests did not exercise. The output is a single fenced Python block as requested.
The response implements a standard sort-then-sweep merge that correctly handles overlapping and touching intervals, passes every test, and returns a single code block with no extra prose as instructed. Its main weakness is that it mutates the caller's input: it sorts the supplied list in place and writes into the original interval lists when extending a merged interval. A copy of the intervals would avoid this side effect. The function is otherwise concise and readable.
Command R 35B 08 2024 gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function sorts intervals by start, merges both overlapping and touching ranges using the correct strict-gap condition, and returns sorted merged intervals. It passed all 10 tests and follows the requirement to provide one Python code block. It mutates the input list and interval sublists, which is a minor quality consideration not prohibited by the task.
The response correctly implements sorting and linear merging after sorting, including the required behavior for intervals that share an endpoint. Its concise single-code-block format also follows the output instruction exactly, and all supplied tests pass. One minor weakness is that it sorts the caller’s list in place and modifies existing interval sublists when extending a merge. Since the task does not require preserving inputs, this does not undermine correctness, but copying the intervals could make the function safer for general use.
All 10 tests pass. The merge logic is correct: it sorts by start, merges when the next start is at or below the current end, and uses max for the end. The code mutates the caller's input, both sorting the list in place and writing into the original inner lists, which the tests did not exercise.
The response implements the standard sort-then-sweep approach, and its merge condition correctly treats touching intervals as mergeable, which the programmatic tests confirm. Its main weakness is side effects: it sorts the caller's list in place and modifies the original interval sublists when merging. A copy of each interval would avoid altering the input, and the response does not address this. The code is otherwise short and idiomatic.
Deepseek Coder 33B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
All 10 tests passed. The function sorts intervals, merges overlapping and touching ranges using the correct strict separation check, and returns sorted merged intervals in a single Python code block. It omits the requested list annotations and mutates the input list and interval sublists, though neither affected the tested behavior.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic implementation that correctly handles unsorted intervals, overlap, and endpoint touching. Its single code block also follows the requested output shape without explanatory text. A minor weakness is that it sorts the caller’s list in place and modifies interval sublists while merging, which may be surprising to callers even though the task does not prohibit mutation. It also omits the explicit `list` parameter and return annotations shown in the requested signature.
All ten tests pass. The sort-and-sweep logic correctly merges touching intervals using the strict `<` check. However, `intervals.sort()` reorders the caller's list, and `merged[-1][1] = ...` mutates the original inner lists, a latent side effect the tests did not catch.
The response passes all ten tests with a concise sort-and-sweep approach that correctly merges touching intervals through its strict less-than comparison. Its main weakness is that it mutates the caller's data: intervals.sort() reorders the input list in place, and extending merged intervals rewrites the original inner lists. The output is correct for the stated examples, but these side effects are unexpected. Copying the intervals before sorting and merging would avoid them. The reply contains only one code block, as requested.
dolphin-2.9.1-yi-1.5-34b gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The implementation passes all 10 tests and correctly sorts, merges overlapping intervals, merges touching intervals via >=, and handles empty input. However, it does not follow the required output shape because it omits the single Python code fence, and it mutates the input list and interval sublists.
The response provides a concise, functional implementation that correctly handles unsorted intervals, overlap, touching endpoints, and empty input, as confirmed by all tests passing. Its main weakness is instruction compliance: the task explicitly required exactly one Python code block, but the function was returned as unformatted plain text. Additionally, sorting and updating the original nested lists mutate the caller’s input, which is an avoidable side effect even though it does not affect the tested behavior.
All 10 tests pass per the programmatic verdict. The code sorts the intervals, then merges when the current start is less than or equal to the previous end, which covers touching intervals as the task requires. It returns a single code block with no explanation, as instructed. It mutates the caller's input list via sort and aliases the inner lists into the result, a minor hygiene issue.
The response implements a standard sort-then-sweep merge. Its strength is correct handling of touching intervals through the inequality check, and it returns only the requested code block with no added prose. Its main weakness is that it sorts the input list in place and reuses the caller's inner list objects in the result, so the caller's data can be modified as a side effect. The function is otherwise concise and idiomatic, and it handles the empty-input case explicitly.
EXAONE-3.5-7.8B-Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
All 10 tests passed. The function sorts by start, merges intervals when the next start is at most the current end, correctly handling overlap and touching endpoints, and returns sorted results in one Python code block. It also handles empty input.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic implementation that directly follows the requested signature and output format. Sorting before a single merge pass correctly handles unsorted input, and the inclusive comparison merges touching intervals as required. A minor weakness is that it sorts the caller’s list in place and reuses its inner lists, so merging can mutate the input data. The task does not prohibit mutation, however, and this behavior does not prevent the implementation from satisfying the tested requirements.
All 10 tests pass and the sweep-and-merge logic is correct, handling overlap and touching via `current[0] <= last_merged[1]`. It sorts the caller's list in place and mutates the input sublists through `last_merged[1]`, a latent side effect the tests did not hit. The reply is a single code block as requested.
The response implements the standard sort-then-sweep approach, which correctly merges both overlapping and touching intervals and returns them ordered by start. Its main weakness is side effects: it sorts the caller's input list in place and writes merged ends into the original interval lists, so the input is altered after the call. The formatting follows the instruction for one Python code block with no added explanation.
Exaone3.5 32B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
All 10 tests passed. The function sorts by start, merges overlapping or touching intervals using the correct <= condition, handles empty input, and returns sorted results in one Python code block. It mutates the input list and interval elements in place, which is not prohibited but is a minor design limitation.
The response correctly implements the required interval merging behavior, including unsorted inputs, touching endpoints, and empty input. Its use of the <= comparison directly captures the task’s definition of touching intervals, and the output follows the requested single-code-block format. A minor weakness is that sorting and updating the intervals occur in place, so the caller’s input list and nested interval data may be modified unexpectedly. The task does not prohibit mutation, and the complete test pass indicates this behavior did not affect the evaluated cases.
All 10 tests pass and the sort-then-sweep logic correctly merges touching intervals. However, the code sorts the caller's list in place and mutates the original inner lists via last_merged[1] assignment, a side effect the tests did not exercise. Output is a single code block as requested.
The response implements the standard approach: sort by start, then sweep while merging any interval whose start is at or below the current end. This correctly handles touching intervals such as [1, 3] and [3, 5], and the empty-input case is covered. The main weakness is that it mutates the caller's input, both by sorting the list in place and by writing into the original interval lists when extending a merged range. Copying the intervals before processing would avoid this latent side effect. The answer is otherwise concise and follows the single-code-block instruction.
gemma-3-27b-it gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests, sorts intervals by start, merges overlapping or endpoint-touching ranges using `<=`, and handles empty input. It follows the requested single-code-block format. It mutates the input list and interval sublists in place, an unrequested side effect, so it is not fully robust.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic implementation that correctly handles unsorted intervals, overlap, touching endpoints, and empty input. Its use of a sorted traversal and updating the current merged endpoint is appropriate and evidently satisfies every supplied test. A weakness is that it sorts the caller’s list in place and modifies the original interval objects through `merged[-1][1]`. Although this behavior is not prohibited by the task and does not affect the tested result, copying the intervals would avoid surprising side effects and make the function safer for general use.
All 10 tests pass and the sort-then-merge logic is correct, including touching intervals via the <= check. The code mutates the caller's input: it sorts the list in place and writes into the original inner lists through merged[-1][1]. That side effect is a latent issue the tests did not hit.
The response implements a standard sort-then-merge approach that correctly handles overlapping and touching intervals, with the touching case covered by the less-than-or-equal comparison. It returns a single code block as requested, with no extra explanation. Its main weakness is that it mutates the caller's input. It sorts the list in place and writes into the original inner interval lists while merging, so a caller who reuses that data will see altered values. The function does not copy the intervals to avoid this side effect.
gemma-3-4b-it gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests, sorts intervals by start, merges overlapping and touching ranges with the correct <= condition, and returns [] for empty input. It follows the requested single-code-block format and provides only the function.
The response correctly implements the required interval merge behavior. It sorts the input, tracks the current merged range, and extends that range for both overlap and endpoint touching, including chained merges. The empty-input case is handled explicitly, and the requested output shape is respected with one Python code block. One minor design consideration is that it sorts and mutates interval elements in place, but the task does not prohibit input mutation and this does not undermine the tested requirements.
All 10 tests pass. The code sorts by start, then merges when the next start is at or below the current end, so touching intervals merge correctly. It returns a single code block with no explanation. It mutates the caller's input: it sorts the list in place and writes into the original sublists, a side effect the task did not ask for.
The response implements the standard sort-then-sweep approach, and its merge condition correctly treats touching intervals as mergeable, which the tests confirm. It returns one code block with no added prose, as instructed. Its weakness is side effects: it sorts the caller's list in place and modifies the original interval sublists when merging. A copy-based implementation would avoid altering the input. Otherwise the logic is compact and readable.
Granite3 Dense 2B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
All 10 tests passed. The function correctly handles empty input, sorts intervals by start, merges overlapping or touching ranges using >=, and returns separated ranges in order. It follows the requirement to provide one Python code block containing only the function.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic implementation that correctly sorts the intervals and merges ranges when they overlap or touch. It also handles empty input without errors and matches the requested output shape. A minor weakness is that it sorts the caller’s list in place and mutates interval sublists while merging, which could surprise callers if input preservation were expected. That behavior is not prohibited by the task and did not affect the supplied tests.
All 10 tests pass and the sort-and-merge logic is correct, with touching intervals merged via >=. However, it sorts the caller's list in place and mutates the caller's inner interval lists through merged[-1][1], a latent side-effect bug the tests did not exercise. Output is one code block as requested.
The response implements the standard sort-then-sweep merge, correctly treating touching intervals such as [1, 3] and [3, 5] as mergeable and passing every test. Its main weakness is that it mutates the input: it sorts the caller's list in place and writes merged bounds into the original inner lists. The result is correct for the tests but can surprise callers who reuse their input. The reply follows the single-code-block instruction without extra explanation.
Granite3 Moe 1B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The verdict reports only 1/10 tests passed. The implementation compares an integer to the list `merged`, causing a TypeError on nonempty input, and it does not sort intervals or return a list of merged intervals. It also includes explanatory text despite the requirement for one code block only.
The response does provide a function with the requested name and accepts an intervals argument, which may account for limited success on an empty-input case. However, its first comparison attempts to evaluate an integer against a list, so ordinary inputs fail immediately. It also overwrites rather than accumulates results, assumes input order, mishandles the output shape, and adds prose outside the sole requested code block. The explanation incorrectly claims that the implementation merges intervals correctly.
Programmatic verdict is 1/10 passed, placing the response in the 0-2 band. The code has a type bug: it compares interval[0] <= merged (an int against a list), which raises TypeError on the first iteration with a nonempty input. It also returns a single interval rather than a list of merged intervals, and the trailing explanation violates the 'no explanation' instruction.
The response attempts a single-pass merge, but the logic is fundamentally broken. The condition comparing an integer start against the list merged raises an error on the first loop iteration, so the function cannot process typical inputs. Even if that comparison were fixed, the function accumulates only one interval and returns a flat pair rather than a sorted list of merged intervals. It also never sorts the input, which the task requires. The response additionally includes a lengthy prose explanation despite the instruction to return only a code block, and that explanation describes logic the code does not implement.
Granite3 Moe 3B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The implementation passes 9/10 tests and correctly sorts intervals, merges overlap or touching ranges, and returns ordered results. Its main weakness is that it indexes intervals[0] without handling an empty input, likely causing the missed test. It also mutates the input list and its interval contents.
The response provides a concise, runnable implementation using sorting and a single merge pass. It correctly treats touching intervals as mergeable through the inclusive endpoint comparison and preserves sorted output. However, it assumes the input contains at least one interval, so an empty list raises an IndexError rather than returning an empty list. The implementation also sorts and mutates the caller’s list, which may be undesirable depending on the expected contract. The single Python code block follows the requested output shape, and no unnecessary explanation is included.
Programmatic verdict is 9/10 passed, which sits in the partial band (3-6), near the top given the high fraction. The code merges touching and overlapping intervals correctly and sorts the output. It crashes on empty input (intervals[0] index error) and mutates the caller's list via sort and in-place edits of inner lists, which likely explains the one failing test.
The response implements a standard sort-then-sweep approach that correctly merges both overlapping and touching intervals, matching the core examples and returning results sorted by start. Its main weakness is robustness: it indexes intervals[0] without checking for an empty input, which raises an error rather than returning an empty list. It also sorts the caller's list in place and mutates the inner interval lists during merging, side effects the task did not request. The code is concise and idiomatic otherwise, and it follows the single-code-block instruction without extra commentary.
Granite3.2 2B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests, sorts intervals by start, merges overlapping or touching ranges using `current[0] <= last[1]`, handles empty input, and returns the required merged list in a single Python code block.
The response correctly implements the requested interval merge behavior. It sorts the input, combines intervals when they overlap or touch, preserves the furthest endpoint, and handles an empty list. It also follows the output-shape instruction by providing exactly one Python code block with no explanation. The implementation mutates the input list and may reuse interval objects while merging, but neither behavior violates the stated task, and the complete test result confirms functional correctness.
All 10 tests pass per the programmatic verdict, so the score is in the 7-10 band. The code is a clean, idiomatic sort-then-merge that correctly uses the touching condition (current[0] <= last[1]) and returns a single code block as requested. It mutates the input list in place and does not copy intervals, a minor latent concern, so it does not reach 9-10.
The response implements the standard sort-and-sweep approach for merging intervals. It correctly treats touching endpoints as mergeable through the <= comparison and returns an empty list for empty input. It delivers exactly one Python code block with no extra explanation, as instructed. A weakness is that it sorts the caller's list in place and reuses the input interval objects, mutating them when merging, which could surprise callers who expect the input to remain unchanged. The code is otherwise concise and readable.
Granite3.2 8B Instruct gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
All 10 tests passed. The function sorts intervals, merges overlapping or touching ranges using `current_start <= last_end`, and returns sorted results in a single Python code block. It omits the requested type annotations and mutates the input list, but neither prevents the required behavior.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic implementation that correctly handles empty input, unsorted intervals, overlap, and endpoint touching. Its use of a sorted traversal and maximum endpoint is appropriate, and it follows the requirement to return one code block without explanation. A minor weakness is that the function signature omits the explicitly requested `list` annotations. It also sorts and partially modifies the caller’s input structure, which could be undesirable if non-mutating behavior were expected, although that behavior was not specified and all supplied tests passed.
All 10 tests pass and the sort-then-sweep logic is correct for overlapping and touching intervals. However, the code sorts the caller's list in place and reuses the input inner lists, so the input is mutated. The response uses a single code block with no explanation, as requested.
The response implements the standard sort-and-sweep approach, correctly merging overlapping and touching intervals and returning results sorted by start, and it passes every test. Its main weakness is that it mutates the caller's data: it sorts the input list in place and modifies the original inner lists when extending merged intervals. The tests did not expose this side effect, so it is a latent defect. The output format follows the instruction to return only one code block.
Granite3.3 8B gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests, sorts intervals, merges overlapping and touching ranges using `current_start <= last_end`, and handles empty input. It returns the expected merged structure in a single Python code block. It omits the requested type annotations and mutates the input list and its first interval, which are minor quality concerns.
The response correctly implements the central interval-merging algorithm: it sorts by start, tracks the latest merged endpoint, and combines intervals that overlap or touch. It also handles an empty input and follows the requested single-code-block output format. A minor weakness is that it sorts the caller’s list in place and reuses the first interval’s nested list, so the input can be modified as a side effect. It also leaves out the explicit `list` annotations shown in the requested signature, although these omissions do not affect the tested behavior.
All 10 tests pass and the merge logic is correct, including touching intervals such as [1,3] and [3,5]. The function sorts the caller's list in place and mutates the inner lists it receives, a latent side effect the tests did not exercise. It returns exactly one code block as requested.
The response implements the standard sort-and-sweep approach, which correctly merges overlapping and touching intervals and returns them sorted by start. It is concise and follows the single-code-block instruction. Its weakness is that it sorts the input list in place and writes into the caller's interval lists through the merged references, so the input is altered after the call. Copying the intervals before merging would avoid this side effect without changing the results.
Granite4 1B H gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests and correctly sorts, merges overlapping intervals, handles touching endpoints, and returns an empty list for empty input. However, it omits the required single Python code block and sorts and mutates the input list in place.
The response provides a concise, working implementation that correctly handles unsorted intervals, overlap, touching boundaries, and empty input. Its merging condition uses the required inclusive endpoint behavior, and the programmatic results confirm full functional correctness. A weakness is that it does not follow the requested output shape: the function is presented as plain text rather than inside one Python code block. It also mutates the caller’s list through in-place sorting and may reuse interval objects, which is not prohibited but is an avoidable side effect.
All 10 tests pass per the programmatic verdict. The code sorts by start, merges when current start <= last end (correctly handling touching intervals), and returns early on empty input. It is concise and idiomatic. It mutates the caller's input list via sort and aliases inner lists when appending, a minor latent side effect. Single code block, no explanation, as instructed.
The response implements the interval merge with a sort by start followed by a single linear pass, and its merge condition correctly treats touching intervals such as [1, 3] and [3, 5] as mergeable. It handles the empty-input case explicitly and returns only one code block, as the task required. A weakness is that it sorts the caller's list in place and reuses the original inner list objects in the output, so the input is silently mutated. Copying the intervals before sorting would avoid this side effect. The code is otherwise clean and short.
Granite4 350M H gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests and correctly sorts intervals, merges overlaps, and handles touching endpoints through the strict separation check. However, it mutates the input list and its interval sublists, and it does not follow the instruction to return one Python code block.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic sweep after sorting and correctly treats equal endpoints as touching intervals, which is reflected by the complete test success. Its main weakness is instruction compliance: the output contains bare code rather than a Python code block, and the implementation mutates both the supplied outer list and interval entries while merging. Those side effects may be undesirable for callers even though they were not exposed by the tests.
All 10 tests pass per the programmatic verdict. The code sorts by start, merges with the correct touching condition (merged[-1][1] < interval[0] keeps separate only on strict gap), and extends the end with max. Returns a single clean code block with no explanation, as requested. Minor issue: it mutates the input list and the stored interval objects, which the task did not forbid but is a latent side effect.
The response implements the standard sort-then-sweep approach. Its merge condition correctly treats touching intervals such as [1, 3] and [3, 5] as mergeable, and it takes the maximum endpoint when extending a merged interval. It returns exactly one Python code block with no prose, matching the requested output shape. A weakness is that it sorts the caller's list in place and appends references to the original inner lists, so the input is mutated as a side effect. The function is otherwise concise and idiomatic, and all listed tests passed.
Granite4.2 30B gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes all 10 tests, sorts intervals by start, merges overlapping or touching ranges using `<=`, handles empty input, and returns the required structure in one code block. It is clean and idiomatic, though it mutates the input list and nested intervals in place.
The response correctly implements sorting, overlap detection, touching-interval merging, and range extension, including the empty-input case. It also follows the required one-code-block output format without explanation. A minor weakness is that it sorts the caller’s list in place and may modify the endpoint of an interval through shared references, which is not necessarily expected from a merge utility even though it does not affect the stated examples or tested behavior.
All 10 tests pass. The code sorts by start and merges with max() on the end, handling touching intervals and empty input. However, it sorts the caller's list in place and assigns into merged[-1][1], which mutates the caller's inner interval lists. The tests did not catch this side effect.
The response implements a standard sort-then-sweep merge that correctly handles overlapping, touching, and unsorted inputs and returns an empty list for empty input. Its main weakness is that it mutates the caller's data: it sorts the input list in place and modifies the original inner interval lists through aliasing. A copy of each interval would avoid this side effect. The response contains one code block, as requested, with no extra explanation.
Laguna XS 2.1 gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
All 10 tests passed. The function sorts by start, merges both overlapping and touching intervals using `current[0] <= last[1]`, handles empty input, and returns sorted output in the requested single code block. It mutates interval objects from the input while merging, which is a minor latent concern if input preservation is expected.
The response provides a concise, idiomatic implementation that correctly handles unsorted input, empty input, overlap, touching endpoints, and sorted output. Its use of a sorted copy avoids reordering the original list, and the merge condition matches the task precisely. A minor weakness is that it stores original interval lists in `merged` and updates their end values in place, thereby mutating caller-provided data. The task does not explicitly prohibit this, and the complete test result confirms the required cases passed.
All 10 tests pass and the code is a standard sort-and-merge with correct touching-interval handling via `current[0] <= last[1]`. It mutates the caller's inner lists in place (`merged[-1][1] = ...`), a latent side effect the tests did not exercise. Output is a single code block as requested.
The response implements the expected sort-then-sweep approach, correctly merging both overlapping and touching intervals and returning results sorted by start, and it passes every test. Its main weakness is that it writes into the input sublists when extending a merged interval, so the caller's data is altered as a side effect. Copying the first interval before mutating would have avoided this. The output follows the single-code-block instruction with no extra prose, and the code is concise and readable.
Lfm2.5 Thinking 1.2B gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
All 10 tests passed, and the merge condition correctly handles overlapping and touching intervals after sorting by start. However, the response omitted the required single Python code block and mutates both the input list and interval sublists, which is an avoidable side effect.
The response provides a concise, working implementation that sorts intervals, merges touching ranges using the inclusive comparison, and returns the expected structure. Its main weakness is instruction adherence: the task explicitly requested one Python code block, but the function was returned as un fenced plain text. The implementation also sorts the caller’s list in place and modifies existing interval objects while merging, behavior that may surprise callers even though it passed all supplied tests. These issues prevent it from being fully polished despite its functional correctness.
All 10 tests pass per the programmatic verdict. The code sorts by start, merges overlapping or touching intervals using the condition interval[0] <= last[1], and returns a single code block with no extra text, as instructed. One latent issue: it sorts and mutates the caller's input list and inner lists in place, which is a minor cleanliness concern rather than a correctness failure.
The response implements a standard sort-then-sweep merge. It correctly treats touching endpoints as mergeable through the less-than-or-equal comparison, and it returns only a single Python code block as the task requested. Its main weakness is side effects: it sorts the caller's list and mutates the inner interval lists in place, so the input is altered after the call. A copy of the intervals would avoid this. The solution is otherwise concise and idiomatic, and it passed the full test set.
Llama-2-7b-chat-hf gap 2
Judged by J-O + J-A.
The function passes only 2/10 tests. It does not sort unsorted input, uses `min` instead of `max` when merging endpoints, and appends the current interval on every iteration, producing duplicates or incorrect results. It also fails to reliably merge overlapping intervals.
The response does provide a syntactically valid function inside a single Python code block and attempts a linear interval-processing approach. However, it omits the required sorting step, so unsorted inputs cannot be handled, and its merge condition and endpoint update are incorrect: `current[1] <= interval[0]` does not represent overlap correctly, while `min` shrinks rather than extends an interval. Appending every iteration also creates duplicate output entries. These defects explain the low test-pass rate.
The verdict is 2/10, so the score falls in the 'some tests passed' band near the low end. The code does not sort the input, never merges overlapping intervals correctly (it takes min instead of max for the end, and never extends current when overlapping), and appends duplicate references to the same list. It runs, but most cases fail.
The response provides a single Python code block with the requested signature, which satisfies the output-shape instruction. However, the algorithm is fundamentally incorrect: it omits sorting the input by start, uses min() rather than max() when combining endpoints, and appends the same interval object repeatedly, so overlapping inputs produce duplicated or truncated results. The condition for merging also only handles strictly non-overlapping touching cases incorrectly. The code runs without crashing, but only a small fraction of test cases pass.
The other 198 models
Their judges were closer together. Their scores are listed here; open the model's page for the full answer.
Withheld
These models are kept out of the ranking, so none of their scores or reasons are shown:
The judge room names the judges and shows where they disagree most.